Got around to testing this one out yesterday, lovely balance of warmth and woodiness, perfect for a chilly fall day. In some ways, I can understand where this might be viewed as 'simple' - but that certainly doesn't mean its - bad. Quite the opposite imho, I would view this scent as highly versatile, somewhat understated and quite classy. Sure, its not necessarily going to amaze or astound you, but its very well done and the performance was pretty decent also. One of those, that if I saw a great deal on it, I may well add to my collection - given the afore mentioned versatility it would make a great office or Swiss army knife option. I suppose one caveat would be, if you really don't find woody fragrances appealing, then definitely don't blind buy!