Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More

Memberships

Sam Macer's Perfumery Academy

497 members • Free

Brotherhood Of Scent

9.4k members • Free

Watch Lover | Community

2.6k members • Free

6746 contributions to Brotherhood Of Scent
FRESHIE FACE-OFF: Niche Luxury vs. Designer Icon!
I pitted two of the most popular fresh aromatic fougères against each other: Parfums de Marly Percival and Montblanc Legend! One is the $400 niche powerhouse, the other is the $130 designer staple. They share a similar clean, refined, barbershop-style DNA, but which one does it better—and which one deserves a spot in your collection? The Question is Simple: Which one is your King of Fresh? Let me know your pick below, and then find out my winner (and why one of them feels like a luxury "dupe" of the other) in the full review here: PDM Percival vs Montblanc Legend: $400 "Clone" vs $130 Original!
Poll
11 members have voted
4 likes • 2h
@Dave Anderson And Quality smell as I own Both?
3 likes • 2h
@Dave Anderson Ok, please do as I own both, and I am not a fan of PDM, but in this case, the quality is far superior!!! Actually, Percival was gifted to me didn't even pay for it.
Got this on the fragrance foundation wiki page
Most Popular men's fragrance for the year. What fragrance was Popular for your birth year (if it's on there doesn't go back very long) 51 yrs back and would you wear it now... mine is 1985 drakkar noir. O actually did own it when I was like 10yrs old
Got this on the fragrance foundation wiki page
1 like • 2h
@Blake Merl Yeah sure!!!
1 like • 2h
This looks like a Buffet of Designer Fragrances!!!
Mail Call Pasion by RDZ
I may not be at ScentXplore, but I get to enjoy one of the perks. A tropical fruit punch with a spike of booze.
Mail Call Pasion by RDZ
1 like • 3h
@Andrew G. I ordered mine first. I don't understand how you got yours!!! LOL
1 like • 2h
@Blake Merl Same!!!!
Sotd: Oud X by Benjamin Barber
A sweet punchy oud fragrance that i really enjoy wearing!
Sotd: Oud X by Benjamin Barber
1 like • 2h
@Arvid Vedestig, I'm very happy that you enjoy wearing this fragrance. I'm more curious as to what the performance is on you. Does it last? Does it project? Is there sillage?
Is it just me?
@Mike Jermann asked about pet peeves in his post https://www.skool.com/bos/whats-some-of-your-pet-peeves-about-the-fragrance-world?p=e073eff6 and my biggest pet peeve is house not offering smaller bottle sizes with a a relative appropriate price. As my collection grows and I still want to add way more variety, when I see a bottle only offered in a 100ml or larger or a ridiculous high priced 50ml, I just walk away, sometime never getting a bottle from that house. I still do buy 100ml, but mostly for frags that I MUST have or the price is way too good to pass up, but I like to share my treasures so that's a win win. Size is part of the biggest reason why I started with Dua and at 70+ now. Is it just me r do you any of you do the same thing?
Is it just me?
1 like • 2h
Dua is expensive on a price per mil basis and the perfume part of it is not what's most expensive. Ordering all the atomizers in bottles, that's where the cost is. It's really easy to use the same atomizer and bottle or a bigger bottle and add more perfume, but the atomizers will get you.
1-10 of 6,746
@lon-chaneyfield-6223
Lover of all Things Fragrance!!!

Active 1h ago
Joined Oct 19, 2025
Powered by