I finally got my nose on By Kilian Angels’ Share, mostly because it made such a strong run in the Booze War and I wanted to understand what made it so appealing. Is it really as great as many have described, or does it push you to a dupe, leaving you feeling less than satisfied? This one’s made the rounds here more than a few times, so most of you know it well, but for anyone who hasn’t had their nose on it yet, it opens with a rich cognac note, warm and slightly sweet, then moves into a spiced heart of cinnamon, tonka, and oak before settling into a cozy base of praline, vanilla, and sandalwood that feels made for cooler weather. That first spray of my decant stopped me in my tracks. It was one of the most beautifully complex openings I can remember smelling, with so much happening at once that it felt almost suspended in time. I’ll remember it as me sitting on my enclosed porch, watching the snow sparkle in the sun as I took it in. The setting was perfect, and maybe that was the problem, because nothing really is. As it began to move and settle into its richer, more familiar form, all I could think was that I wished it had stayed right there, not because what came next was bad, but because what it was felt rarer than what it became. I get why this one has its following, and I also get why some of you bounce off it. By the time it settled into that rich, spicy, woody character, it hardly resembled the sweet warmth of the cognac that opened it. Had that initial, beautifully complex impression remained, this one would have truly commanded its price tag. For me, the experience was less about liking or disliking it and more about realizing how much I value those fleeting moments when a fragrance feels impossibly alive before choosing a direction. That said, since it doesn’t match my clean-and-fresh scent profile, it’s not something I’d typically reach for to wear out. But as a decant and a curiosity, I’m glad I sprung for it, and I don’t regret the experience at all.

This one feels like a “clean luxury” scent with an old-school backbone. The vibe is polished and classy, but not dusty—more like a crisp button-down with a warm, slightly textured base. The opening comes off bright and smooth (not sharp), then it settles into that comforting “expensive soap + soft woods” territory. What I like is how put together it smells. It’s not trying to be loud or weird, and it doesn’t scream for attention. It’s the type of fragrance that makes you smell fresh and intentional without smelling like you’re wearing “a fragrance,” if that makes sense. Scent profile (how it wears on me) - Opening: clean, slightly bright, airy - Mid: creamy/soft aromatic feel, like refined cleanliness - Drydown: smooth woods + a gentle musky warmth that sticks close Performance - Longevity: solid—lasts most of the day on skin - Projection: moderate for the first hour or two, then becomes more intimate - Sillage: clean trail, not a room-filler When I’d wear it Perfect for work, errands, date nights where you don’t want something heavy, or anytime you want to smell “fresh but grown.” Great signature scent energy. Overall If you’re into clean, classy, understated scents (more refined than “freshie gym spray,” less intense than heavy ambers), NM 1907 is an easy win. Not the most “unique,” but it’s the kind of scent that’s hard to dislike and easy to reach for.