User
Write something
Live Q&A w/Jonathan is happening in 6 hours
Blaming your subject line? Wrong problem. ❌
Stop blaming your subject line. Your cold email copy isn't the problem. Your LIST is. The variable 90% of people skip: company size. A 5-person startup and a 50-person company are completely different buyers. Same email to both = you're leaving half your pipeline on the table. Here's how they break down: Small companies (under 10 people) - The founder feels the pain personally - Lead magnets actually work - Education-first content moves them to reply Bigger companies (20-50+ people) - They don't care about your free thing - Lead magnets lose effectiveness fast - Their only question: "Is this person the right one to solve my problem?" One is a value game. The other is a credibility game. You can't fix a targeting problem with better copy. Period. What's the company size breakdown on your current outreach? 🧠
450 cold emails on day one, first call booked 2 minutes after Email 1
Most advice says expect nothing in the first few weeks. On Nov 7 I launched and a CEO of a 40-year-old web design agency replied "Thursday will work" 2 minutes after Email 1 went out. One call doesn't prove a campaign, but here's the setup behind it: 1. 3 niches x 2 offers = 6 campaigns, split 50/50, so the data picks the offer and I don't have to guess. 2. 15 mailboxes warmed about 25 days at 100% health, then 30 emails a day each. That's the 450. 3. A personal first line for every lead, written from their own website. 4. Plain text, no links, no tracking. Email 2 on day 3 opens with the offer itself, Email 3 on day 7 is a lower friction ask. The part that went wrong: 6 to 11% bounces on day one. Instantly's verifier flagged 300 of my 1,468 leads as bad, even though the scraper had marked them validated. They're gone now and every new lead gets verified before upload. Screenshot is the simple sheet with the real day one numbers. What did your first day of sending look like?
450 cold emails on day one, first call booked 2 minutes after Email 1
Are you still pitching your agency in the first email?
The best cold emailers I know aren't selling anything. Sounds backwards. It's not. Cold email works best when you flip the ask. Partnerships. Affiliates. Getting hired. Giving something first. The minute you stop trying to close and start asking them to bring you on... reply rates move fast. Here's how it plays out in real life: You run a cybersecurity firm. Everyone in your space is pitching $5K/month retainers and landing in the spam folder. Instead? Email those same people and ask to be their fractional CISO. Same expertise. Same price. Different title. You're not asking them to trust an agency they've never heard of. You're asking them to hire a person for a role they already know they need. See, here's the thing - the harder your industry is to sell into, the more the reframe matters. With cold email you can put your message in front of a million potential buyers. The question is what you're asking for when you get there. What's your niche? Drop it below and let's workshop your angle together. 👇
Structured or Flexible?
Running a business means no routine. A corporate job means no flexibility. I need both. From the owner side I take the drive: no fixed schedule, long hours when something needs them, and no waiting for approval. I build for myself first, then for others. From the corporate side I take the discipline: routine, structure, and the communication skills I picked up working with a founder who came from a job-sector background. For those of you running agencies or freelancing: are you more structured or more flexible? And what’s the one routine you’d never give up?
How do you do outbound?
If I ran outbound for you for 30 days, this is the order: Week 1: business model, offer, start infrastructure (pre-warmed mailboxes or your own domains warmed up) Week 2: warm-up continues, build the ICP list and batch it for testing Week 3: prospect research and enrichment, personalize, launch at the end of the week Week 4: run the batches, review the offer, ICP and copy Then keep optimizing. It’s an ongoing process, not a one-month fix. For those of you running outbound: do you sequence it the same way? What do you do differently?
1-30 of 3,927
Lead Gen Secrets
skool.com/lead-gen
Cold email training & lead generation systems. Automate cold outreach with AI to attract high-quality B2B leads and get clients on autopilot.
Leaderboard (30-day)
Powered by