Notes from Alexandra Greifeld's Guest Lecture

Thank you to everyone who joined us live for Alex's guest lecture. Here are the notes from Alex's lecture. This will be the only time I upload guest lecture notes publicly.

I'll upload the recording to the Call Recordings in the Classroom later today or tomorrow. If you want it, and all our other guest lecture recordings (plus 13 paid courses), upgrade to Premium.

https://www.skool.com/copywriting-launchpad/plans

Our next guest lecture is with Kyle Milligan this Friday at 10 am EST. It's free to join us live. The recording will be made available for Premium members.

https://www.skool.com/copywriting-launchpad/calendar?eid=29d4d0218f014c629cfb9e87890f9fa0

Quick Summary

Alex Greifeld discussed her path from fashion design into e-commerce growth, consulting, newsletters, and courses. The core theme of the call was that marketing performance is often downstream of product, merchandising, pricing, margins, and customer psychology. Better copy, ads, or email marketing cannot always fix a weak product, poor margins, unrealistic ROAS expectations, or an undifferentiated offer.

She also explained how the market has changed. Social algorithms now behave more like TikTok’s For You Page, which makes it harder to grow by sharing niche expertise alone. AI has also changed buyer psychology because some clients now assume AI can replace copywriters, media buyers, or strategists, even when that is not really true.

The Big Takeaways

Merchandising is a growth lever. Brands need product pathways that give customers reasons to come back and buy again.
The product is often the angle. This is especially true in fashion, where copy cannot convince someone to want a product they do not visually like.
KPI systems can miss the real problem. A brand can track performance metrics while missing deeper issues in product, positioning, or customer psychology.
Direct response still works, but it has limits. Meta can prove demand and capture warm buyers, but many brands eventually need broader brand, retail, content, or awareness strategies.
Not every product is worth working on. Copywriters and consultants should screen early-stage clients for margins, differentiation, compliance constraints, price point, and channel fit.
Content-led client acquisition is harder now. Expertise still matters, but platforms often reward broader, more entertaining content before they reward niche authority.
AI has made buyers more skeptical about paying for execution. Service providers need to emphasize judgment, strategy, diagnosis, taste, and category expertise.

Alex’s Background

Alex Griffeld has worked in digital marketing and e-commerce for roughly 12 years. She began as a women’s wear designer, then moved into digital marketing and e-commerce roles, especially in fashion. Around 2022, she became a consultant and expanded into beauty, wellness, consumer products, and other DTC categories.

Key parts of her current work include:

Consulting on creative strategy, go-to-market strategy, Meta, lifecycle marketing, and merchandising analysis.
Running the newsletter No Best Practices.
Running the fashion-focused newsletter DTC Fashion Decoded.
Creating courses for e-commerce operators and marketers.
Working with or referencing brands such as Jones Road Beauty, Bonobos, Larude, Johnston & Murphy, and Stars and Honey.

How Alex Learned E-Commerce Strategy

A major turning point came while Alex was working at the footwear brand Donald Pliner. The company had been growing, then sales started declining, and no one could clearly explain why. The company was very KPI-driven, but the real problem was strategic and merchandising-related.

The brand had been built around Italian production and designer-level quality at a lower price point. After a private equity acquisition, production moved partly to China, and the brand also made decisions to chase a younger customer. Those changes damaged the reasons customers originally bought from the brand.

Alex’s learning path included:

Reading Kevin Hillstrom after searching for explanations of declining e-commerce sales.
Doing an MBA, where she learned to code and gained a broader understanding of accounting, strategy, and analysis.
Working across different types of brands, from founder-led fashion companies to large corporate environments.
Reading broadly across luxury branding, culture, psychology, creativity, marketing, and business turnarounds.
Following industry sources such as Business of Fashion, Line Sheet, Future Commerce, Glossy, and practitioners on X.

What Merchandising Means

Alex used merchandising to mean more than simply choosing products. In her view, merchandising is about designing the product ecosystem so customers have reasons to buy, return, and buy again.

A simple way to understand it:

If a brand sells only one product, repeat purchase may be limited.
If the product lasts a long time, customers may not need to buy again for years.
Email marketing cannot create repeat purchases if there is nothing else for customers to buy.
The brand needs adjacent products or additional “swim lanes” that make sense for the same customer.

The example Alex gave was Ridge Wallet:

Ridge started with wallets.
A customer may only need one wallet every several years.
That limits repeat purchase.
Ridge expanded into products such as rings, luggage, and gold chains.
The key was that these products fit the same customer, rather than being random add-ons.

Nabeel connected this to course creators and info-product businesses. They often need different front-end offers for different audience segments, awareness stages, or sophistication levels. Alex said she is thinking through this same issue for her own course business.

Buyer Psychology and Intangible Differentiation

Alex emphasized that some of the most important reasons people buy cannot be cleanly captured in a KPI. With Donald Pliner, customers were partly buying into authenticity, Italian production, and a specific brand story. When those things changed, the business suffered, but the KPI dashboard did not clearly reveal the cause.

Her broader point was that many categories are becoming more like fashion:

Fashion has low barriers to entry.
There is little defensible intellectual property beyond trademarks and logos.
Anyone can copy a blue striped shirt.
Therefore, fashion brands need intangible reasons for people to choose them.

Those intangible reasons can include:

Brand mythology.
Taste.
Consistency.
Emotional association.
Cultural relevance.
Customer identity.
Aesthetic point of view.

Alex applied this idea to software as well. In the past, technical complexity was a moat. As AI makes software easier to build, software companies may need stronger intangible differentiation too.

Direct Response vs. Brand Building

Alex said direct response and Meta advertising still matter, but they do not take brands as far as they did a few years ago.

The basic pattern she described:

Meta can help prove that demand exists.
Meta can capture warm, in-market buyers.
Direct response can work well with product-aware audiences.
But once a brand gets beyond warm buyers and early adopters, the strategy gets harder.

At that point, brands often face a choice:

Move into more aggressive problem-aware messaging.
Expand into physical retail.
Invest in organic social, events, brand, and awareness.
Build broader enterprise value instead of only chasing fast paid-media scale.

Alex also discussed the challenge of competing against non-compliant brands. In skincare and supplements, some small brands or affiliates make claims that compliant brands cannot make. Her point was that you cannot direct-response harder than someone who is willing to break the law.

Alex’s Newsletter and Consulting Business

Alex started writing while working in-house because she wanted to explain complicated e-commerce and marketing ideas more clearly. She began on Medium, then later built an audience on Twitter/X and through her newsletter.

Her consulting business grew from that audience:

She used social content to build visibility.
She used the newsletter to stay top-of-mind.
She got client interest from subscribers, followers, and referrals.
She did not always aggressively pitch services through every newsletter issue.

Her current revenue mix, in rough terms:

Newsletter sponsorships are less than 10% of income.
Courses and one-off calls are around 25% of income.
The rest comes from consulting work.

She wants to shift more income toward:

Courses.
Group coaching.
More scalable offers.
Less dependence on one-on-one consulting.

Alex’s Offers and Pricing

Alex described several offer types and price points:

60-minute consulting call: $650, with pre-research included.
Average project: around $5,000 to $6,000, usually over two to four weeks.
Deep-dive project: around $10,000 to $15,000, often involving transaction data, lifecycle analysis, merchandising analysis, segmentation, and impact estimates.
Advisory/coaching retainer: around $1,500 per month for two to four short calls plus Slack or email access.
Part-time creative strategy retainer: around $5,000 per month.
More involved outsourced role: higher monthly fee, depending on scope.

She noted that once projects move above roughly $5,000, the sales process can become more time-consuming. Larger clients may require more vetting, more meetings, decks, procurement, and stakeholder buy-in.

Why Alex Does Not Focus on Media Buying

Alex has run ads before, but she does not currently position herself as a “button pusher” inside ad accounts.

She gave an example where she helped a fashion brand increase spend from about $300 per day to $2,000–$3,000 per day by fixing media buying. But after about a year, the brand brought the work in-house.

Her view on media buying:

It can be valuable when the account is badly managed.
It can be a way to start a client relationship.
But it can also create churn because successful brands eventually bring it in-house.
She prefers strategic work, analysis, creative strategy, and merchandising-related projects.

Creative Strategy vs. Copywriting

Alex said copywriting is a necessary foundation for creative strategy. A good creative strategist needs to understand:

Unique mechanisms.
Sales arguments.
Research.
Empathy.
Customer psychology.
Direct response structure.

But creative strategy adds another layer:

Visual presentation.
Audience-specific content formats.
Asset planning.
Creative testing.
Understanding what kind of content the customer already consumes.

Her example was that visuals that resonate with a 25-year-old woman may not resonate with a 55-year-old man. Creative strategy is not only about what the ad says. It is also about how the idea is visually packaged so the audience finds it credible and familiar.

Fashion Brands and Copywriting

Alex said many fashion brands do not need copywriting in the same way supplements, health products, or problem-solution products do.

In fashion:

The product is often the angle.
If someone does not like pink pants, copy will not persuade them to like pink pants.
The work is often about choosing the right products to promote.
It is also about photographing and filming the right products.
The brand needs an asset development flywheel around what is working.

She contrasted fashion with a brand like True Classic Tees:

True Classic sells basics, not fashion in the high-aesthetic sense.
It has a functional promise: better fit, longer wear, more flattering shape.
That makes it suitable for problem-solution direct response marketing.

Romantic Product Copy and the J. Peterman Style

Nabeel brought up the J. Peterman catalog and older romantic product descriptions.

Alex said that style still exists in spirit, but the execution has changed:

In the past, brands might write a paragraph romanticizing where a garment came from or the scenario around wearing it.
Today, a brand might send the product to an influencer and have them create a lifestyle video.
The same desire-building mechanism exists, but it is now more visual and social-native.

Her practical note:

Longer copy in ads is worth testing.
But the more text an ad uses, the more it tends to resonate with older audiences.
She would not treat long text-heavy ads as a default playbook item for every fashion brand.

Client Needs by Brand Stage

Alex broke down how different brands need different kinds of help.

For pre-revenue brands:

They often need product validation, creative strategy, and early Meta testing.
They may need an experienced operator to tell them what to do and help them find product-market fit.
But they often cannot afford the level of senior help they actually need.
Many also have fundamental product problems.

For brands under $1 million:

The biggest issue may be whether the product is viable at all.
Consultants need to be careful because the problem may not be copy or ads.
Product, margins, differentiation, or demand may be broken.

For brands around $5 million to $30 million:

Alex sees this as her consulting sweet spot.
These brands usually have real product-market fit.
They often have one thing working and need help improving the system.
They may need help with path-to-purchase, customer segmentation, creative strategy, post-purchase marketing, or a new customer avatar.

For brands around $30 million to $50 million:

They become more professionalized.
They often have senior people handling strategy.
They may look for tactical agencies or vendors for email, ads, creative production, or media buying.

For brands around $50 million to $100 million:

The sales process becomes much more complex.
There are more stakeholders.
There may be pitch decks, multiple rounds of meetings, procurement, and formal vendor review.
The best path is often a strong relationship with a decision-maker.

How to Tell If a Product Has Potential

Alex gave criteria for evaluating whether an early-stage product has “legs.” This was especially relevant for copywriters or consultants considering equity, rev-share, or performance-based deals.

Important criteria:

Product margin: A $100 product may need a landed cost around $20–$23 to leave enough room for fulfillment, returns, and marketing.
ROAS expectations: If the business needs a 5x ROAS on every dollar to survive, it may be a hopeless case.
Compliance limits: Supplements, hormone products, scalp serums, acne products, and similar categories may be difficult if the brand cannot make direct claims.
Price point: High-ticket products may not convert within short attribution windows. A $2,000 watch should not be expected to hit 3x ROAS on a seven-day Meta click window.
Differentiation: If the product is the same as everyone else’s, it is hard to sell unless the brand has a strong differentiator or can use very aggressive marketing.
Channel fit: Some products use Meta as demand capture, not full demand generation.
Founder audience: A personal brand can help, but it may not be enough to create scalable paid acquisition.

The practical warning:

Do not take performance-based work just because the founder is excited.
First evaluate margins, differentiation, compliance, price, and channel fit.
Some products are structurally difficult or impossible to sell profitably through paid ads.

Surveying and Segmenting a Newsletter Audience

Alex said her newsletter has strong engagement, with open rates around 55%–58%, but surveys have not received many responses.

Nabeel suggested a better approach:

Do not send a generic survey to the whole list.
Tie the survey to a launch or pre-sale.
Ask people to opt into something specific.
Use the opt-in behavior to tag them.
Ask survey questions as part of that process.

He also mentioned using RightMessage after opt-in:

Add a two- or three-question survey immediately after someone subscribes.
Ask questions when the subscriber is already engaged.
Use the answers to segment the list.

The takeaway is that audience research works better when it is tied to a moment of intent.

Social Algorithms and Content Strategy

Alex said social platforms are increasingly moving toward the TikTok For You Page model.

What this means:

Content is shown to broader random audiences first.
Niche expertise may not reach the right people immediately.
Creators may need to appeal to the “median scroller.”
This can make serious expert content harder to distribute.
The same issue affects ads because individual ads fatigue faster.

For consultants and copywriters:

Demonstrating expertise online still matters.
But it is harder to get the right people to see it.
Content may need a broader vertical or category hook.
For example, instead of only talking about email marketing, someone might talk about skincare trends and then connect that to email marketing for skincare brands.

Alex mentioned Cut30, a short-form video program:

She found it humbling and frustrating.
The first 30 days did not magically create massive success.
She improved through more reps after the program.
The value was improving filming, editing, packaging, and short-form instincts.

How Alex Would Seek Clients if She Was Starting Over Today

Alex said the right approach depends on the person’s background.

If someone has deep corporate experience:

Start with referrals.
Reconnect with former colleagues.
Get into rooms with senior people.
Build from existing professional credibility.

If someone is a freelancer or has a few years of experience:

Demonstrate expertise online.
Consider niching into a vertical if doing content.
Build a body of work.
Use networking and cold outreach.
Build relationships with other service providers.

Alex’s softer outreach approach:

When an interesting brand comes onto her radar, she adds the founder or executive on LinkedIn or X.
She interacts in a non-salesy way.
This builds familiarity.
Three to six months later, pitching becomes easier.

Nabeel added that beginner copywriters should usually not rely only on content. They should build a network, use cold outreach, and create an online body of work as a credibility hedge.

AI and the Service Business Landscape

Alex said AI adoption is one of the biggest industry shifts.

She sees several groups:

People who refuse to use AI.
People who use ChatGPT like a search engine.
Advanced users who have automated large parts of their job.
Very few people in the middle.

She launched an AI product for e-commerce operators, assuming they would want help using AI tools and prompts to understand their business. The product did only “okay,” which made her rethink the positioning.

Her bigger point:

AI has made business owners more hesitant to invest in services.
Some founders think they can use AI instead of a copywriter, media buyer, or strategist.
That is not necessarily true, but it changes how buyers think.
Service providers need to show the value of expert judgment, not just execution.

Direct Response Education for Copywriters

In the final Q&A, Nabeel recommended that new direct response copywriters study financial and health newsletters.

His suggestions included:

Sign up for Agora Financial-style newsletters.
Sign up for MarketWatch and Motley Fool-type financial newsletters.
Get onto health offer email lists.
Study the emails, offers, claims, mechanisms, and sales arguments.
Treat those emails, VSLs, and sales letter as a practical education in direct response.

Most Useful Practical Lessons

Before improving ads, ask whether the product, margin, price, and differentiation are strong enough.
Before accepting rev-share or equity, make sure the product has real upside and workable economics.
In fashion and aesthetic categories, spend more time on product selection, photography, video, and merchandising.
In functional categories, direct response frameworks are more useful because the product solves a clear problem.
If content is part of client acquisition, choose a vertical or category that algorithms can understand and distribute.
Build relationships before pitching, especially with founders and executives.
If AI is affecting your category, position yourself around strategy, diagnosis, taste, and judgment.
If you run a newsletter, collect audience data during opt-ins, launches, or moments of high intent.

Best Quotes and Ideas to Remember

“The product is the angle.”

This is especially true in fashion and aesthetic categories. Creative strategy starts with what people actually want to see and buy.

“You cannot direct-response harder than someone who is willing to break the law.”

This captures the challenge of competing against non-compliant brands or affiliates in categories like skincare and supplements.

“Meta can prove demand, but it may not build the whole business.”

Meta is useful, but some products need broader awareness, retail, brand, or content strategies to keep growing.

“Some products are not marketing problems. They are product problems.”

This is crucial for copywriters and consultants evaluating early-stage brands.

One-Screen Recap

Alex Griffeld’s main message was that e-commerce growth depends on much more than ads and copy. The real constraints are often product, merchandising, margins, price, differentiation, and customer psychology. Her fashion background taught her that intangible reasons to buy matter, especially when products are easy to copy.

For consultants and copywriters, the big lesson is to screen clients carefully. Do not take equity, rev-share, or performance-based deals unless the product has strong margins, real differentiation, manageable compliance constraints, and a realistic channel strategy.

For content and client acquisition, the market is harder than it used to be. Social platforms reward broad, entertaining content, not just niche expertise. Service providers still need a body of work, but they should combine content with referrals, relationships, networking, and outreach.

AI has also changed the market. Some clients now believe AI can replace specialists, so service providers need to prove the value of strategic judgment, diagnosis, taste, and domain expertise.

10 comments