User
Write something
Club De Nuit Intense Man vs Untold
The battle between 2 clone fragrances from Armaf Club De Nuit Intense Man vs Untold. Club De Nuit Intense Man is a popular Creed Aventus clone , Club De Nuit Untold is a clone of Baccarat Rouge 540 and it's a beautiful unisex fragrance loved by men and women. My wins is on Club De Nuit Intense Man because this was one of the first Creed Aventus clones, the EDT already made it legendary clone of Aventus then they came out with EDP, Parfum and etc. Which clone fragrances is your wins?
Poll
6 members have voted
Porthole Dupes side by side comparisons: Dua Starboard, Porthole 10ml Decant, Alexandria Loophole,Montagne Port Azure, Dapper Marine Portal,
Dua Starboard: I’m sorry, but this one is so far from the OG in scent that it shouldn’t be considered a dupe. The opening is a blast of lemonade, the drink. It reminds me of this strawberry lemonade candle from BBW. It is not a bad smell, but it just doesn’t smell like a fragrance you wear on your body. The projection was very strong for the first 3 hours, then fizzles out to a skin scent by hours 4-5. 5/10. Alexandria Loophole: The moment I sprayed this, I could immediately tell it resembled Porthole. Lacking the sea salt and iodine notes from the OG, but the rest of it is all there. The juicy pineapple opening takes over for the first 20 minutes, then it dries down into the passion fruit/ginger. I think the ginger note is slightly overdosed here because there is this smell that I also find in LV L’immensite. It has a light/airy feeling but somehow still projects and lasts 6-7 hours. Not a perfect dupe, but overall a solid alternative to Porthole. 8.5/10. Montagne Port D’Azur: This is wonderful. There are some similarities to the Alexandria dupe, but also a few differences that make it a few points closer to the OG. The opening has that passionfruit mixed in with the pineapple, creating this intoxicating/addictive smell that makes me want to lick the spot on my arm where I sprayed. It’s lacking the sea salt / Iodine just like the Alexandria, but I think it’s for the better. The ginger note here is toned down to perfection. It has the same airy but strong projection/longevity as the OG. Overall, I would say this is a few points higher than the Alexandria version. 8.9/10 Dapper Fragrances: This has everything the Montagne does and the Alexandria, but it does not lack the Seasalt / Iodine like the Alexandria and the Montagne 9.2/10 Loumari Porthole: Well, this is the OG, and it is expensive. It has everything. No need to explain more. Dapper has just a tad bit more longevity, and Montagne is just under the OG The OG is slightly better with the raw materials, but you would have to smell each fragrance at least 20 times to detect the slight difference. In the air tested the top 3 with 4 different employees, and the supermarket Lady could not tell the difference. This included the Porthole, so 4 in total, and all were fully matured. OG 9.5/10
SOTE - TF Oud Voyager
Doing a quick errand and this is one of the last sample/decants that I had set out for this weeks challenges. Love this stuff! Shockingly I walked out of my office and wife complimented it.
SOTE - TF Oud Voyager
Dueling Dupes - Tobacco Vanille vs. Tobacco Touch (re-up'd)
Hey frag fam! Today's frag: Tom Ford's Tobacco Vanille (Maison Alhambra Tobacco Touch) What can I say, Maison Alhambra has such balls to close copy not one, not two, but seven different fragrances from the Tom Ford private blend! With such cajones, I just had to throw this one in the dupe lineup against Tom Ford's highly successful and uber popular Tobacco Vanille. Let's see what we got! Test sprays had TV project loud and strong. So sweet and masculine, I didn't want to overdo it in the warmer Florida climate. Six sprays spread out across chest and shoulders. I put our dupe on my left arm for our comparison wearing. Doing a little research, I found Tobacco Vanille to be a 'linear' fragrance, having largely the same scent profile throughout the wear. And OMG, right out the gate it's a potent tobacco and vanilla scent, very upscale and mature. There are spice notes along the edges that contain and tame the raw power of the main accords. Without balance, this scent would become cloying and overwhelming. Thankfully, the blend is smoothly done and what I get is a wonderfully sophisticated, classy and mature fragrance. Tobacco Touch does its best to copy this profile with it's tobacco notes, but again, is unbalanced, favoring the sweetness from the vanilla and the spices playing more of an NPC role rather than a supporting actor... Throughout the wear, it was Tobacco Touch that was trying to keep up with Tobacco Vanille. TV's projection was much louder and its longevity was much longer than the dupe. Both scents dried down with the tobacco and vanilla notes, but TV anchored them with a woody base that continued its overall sophistication through to the end of the wear. TT petered out with a sticky sweet cinnamon like base. Tobacco Vanille I feel is more for the mature, refined gentleman. It's tobacco scent is smooth and refined while vanilla adds depth and character. Definitely a scent suitable in the colder months only. It could be worn during the day, but leans more toward the nighttime. Also, I see this in more formal settings, like at an upscale bar or wine club or to a formal dinner event. Longevity is beastly, 10+ hrs.
Dueling Dupes - Tobacco Vanille vs. Tobacco Touch (re-up'd)
Battle of the Polo's
Time to choose sides. Pick your Polo! Polo 67 and Polo Green represent two distinct eras of Ralph Lauren masculinity, with Polo 67 leaning into a modern, bright citrus-woody freshness while Polo Green delivers a dense, classic green chypre profile rooted in tradition. Polo 67 opens with lively bergamot and pineapple that feel clean and athletic, whereas Polo Green begins with herbal, spicy, almost forest-like notes that immediately read as deeper and more assertive. As they develop, Polo 67 stays smooth and versatile with aromatic sage and vetiver, while Polo Green evolves into a richer blend of oakmoss, leather, and tobacco that feels heavier and more vintage. In terms of wearability, Polo 67 is easier for everyday use—especially in warm climates—while Polo Green thrives in cooler weather or more formal, evening settings. Ultimately, Polo 67 projects a confident, contemporary “sport luxury” identity, whereas Polo Green embodies a timeless, rugged sophistication that feels rooted in heritage and tradition. Between the two, I give the edge to Polo 67, What say you!
Poll
24 members have voted
Battle of the Polo's
1-30 of 331
Brotherhood Of Scent
#1 Fragrance Community 🏆
Our mission is to help YOU leverage the power of scent to become the man you know yourself to be.
Leaderboard (30-day)
Powered by