The Technician In Your Head vs. The One Standing In Front of You

A lot of shop owners I talk to think they have a communication problem with their techs.

They don't.

They have a recognition problem.

Here's what I mean:

When you talk to "your technicians," you're not actually talking to them. You're talking to a generic technician you invented in your head—some composite of every tech you've ever met, blended with assumptions about "what techs want" you picked up from industry forums and podcast gurus.

Meanwhile, the actual human being in front of you—with specific wiring, specific fears, specific motivators—hears something completely different than what you intended.

And here's the kicker: when communication fails, most owners blame the tech.

"He doesn't listen." "She's impossible to read." "I can't figure out what he wants."

But here's a more uncomfortable truth: the person who controls the message controls the outcome.

When you take full responsibility for 100% of a communication—what you say AND what your tech hears—you've mastered communication.

Everything else is just hoping.

THE SIX TECHNICIANS YOU'RE ACTUALLY MANAGING

After analyzing hundreds of technician conversations, personality assessments, and retention patterns, I've identified six distinct technician types. Each one processes information differently, fears different things, and responds to completely different motivators.

Get this wrong, and your best intentions land like criticism. Get this right, and your simplest feedback becomes fuel.

Here they are:

👉THE DIAGNOSTIC HUNTER

Core identity: "I'm not a parts changer. I solve the weird stuff."

This tech lives for the complex diagnosis. Electrical gremlins. Intermittent faults. The car everyone else gave up on. When the whole shop is panicking, they're calm.

What they're scanning for in every conversation:

"Do you respect diagnosis as paid work?"
"Will I be interrupted or trusted?"
"How do you handle comebacks and blame?"

What makes them leave: Unpaid diag time. Guess-and-swap culture. Getting blamed for comebacks on cars where they weren't given time to verify. Constant "status update" interruptions mid-diagnosis.

How to speak their language: Be calm. Be direct. Be technical. Skip the pep talks—they read as noise.

Instead of: "We really need you to step up and knock out more cars." Try: "I've protected your diagnostic time. The scope's updated. If you need to verify the fix, sell the additional diag."

The one thing they need to hear: "You'll have the time to confirm the fix."

👉THE PRODUCTION PRO

Core identity: "I do it right the first time. You can count on my work."

This is your reliable machine. Consistency is their currency. They show up, follow specs, torque properly, and expect the same standards from everyone else. Drama exhausts them.

What they're scanning for:

"Is the workflow clean and fair?"
"Are procedures real or just talk?"
"Do you value consistency or just speed?"

What makes them leave: Chaotic dispatching. RO changes mid-job. Missing info on work orders. Parts delays. Inconsistent standards—"do it right" until it slows things down, then suddenly it's "just get it done." Favoritism in job assignments.

How to speak their language: Organized. Specific. Policy-based. Respectful.

Instead of: "We're flexible here—things change." Try: "Here's exactly how we run the day. Dispatch rules. RO standards. Parts staging process. No surprises."

The one thing they need to hear: "The workflow is clean and fair."

👉THE FAST MOVING CLOSER

Core identity: "I like being in motion. I want to win my day."

Energetic. Competitive. Momentum-driven. They want to stay busy, earn big, and see a clear path between effort and reward. If they're good, they expect to eat.

What they're scanning for:

"Can I stay moving and earning?"
"Is this shop actually busy?"
"Do good techs get rewarded here?"
"Is leadership strong or weak?"

What makes them leave: Slow shop. Low car count. Red tape. Waiting on approvals and parts all day. Being capped with no upside. Getting stuck with problem cars and no support.

How to speak their language: Confident. Brisk. Opportunity-driven. Show the payoff AND the structure.

Instead of: "We're building something great here—just hang in there." Try: "We stay busy. Workflow's clean. Good techs aren't capped. You'll move cars without chaos."

The one thing they need to hear: "There's no ceiling on what you can earn here."

👉THE SHOP STANDARDS ENFORCER

Core identity: "I can run a clean operation. Standards matter."

This is your natural foreman. They think in systems, accountability, and metrics. Weak leadership makes them itch. Sloppy work from peers makes them frustrated. They want control—and the responsibility that comes with it.

What they're scanning for:

"Do I have the authority to fix what's broken?"
"Are the owners serious about standards?"
"Will I be undermined?"

What makes them leave: Weak management. Inconsistent rules. No accountability. Techs freelancing with no consequences. Zero SOPs. Nobody "owns" the workflow.

How to speak their language: Direct. Structured. Performance-based. Respect their desire to lead—but be clear about boundaries.

Instead of: "We'd love your input on how we can improve." Try: "Here's what you have authority over. Here's what's my call. Now let's build this together."

The one thing they need to hear: "You have authority to implement standards—and I'll back you up."

👉THE CRAFT AND PRIDE SPECIALIST

Core identity: "The details matter. I want it to look and feel right."

Meticulous. Aesthetic-driven. Whether it's restoration work, interior, trim, or just careful reassembly—they care about the finish. Sloppy work physically bothers them.

What they're scanning for:

"Do you actually value quality here?"
"Will I get the time to do it right?"
"Will I be respected or treated like interchangeable labor?"

What makes them leave: Rushed work. Cheap parts. Shortcuts. Being pushed to "just get it out the door." Management that sees them as slow instead of thorough.

How to speak their language: Calm. Appreciative. Detail-aware. Show that you notice what they notice.

Instead of: "We need to pick up the pace." Try: "The work you did on that interior—the customer noticed. That's the standard here."

The one thing they need to hear: "Take the time. Do it right. You'll be proud of what leaves this shop."

👉THE SYSTEMS THINKER

Core identity: "I don't fear complexity. I solve it."

Advanced-level thinking. They're drawn to EV systems, ADAS calibration, network diagnostics, software integration. While other techs see a headache, they see a puzzle worth solving.

What they're scanning for:

"Do you invest in training and modern systems?"
"Is there respect for logic and data here?"
"Will I have time for proper verification?"

What makes them leave: Guesswork culture. Anti-intellectual leadership ("just fix it, don't overthink it"). No investment in training or tooling. Dismissing their approach as "too complicated."

How to speak their language: Intelligent. Curious. Evidence-based.

Instead of: "We don't have time for all that testing." Try: "Walk me through your test plan. What data are you seeing?"

The one thing they need to hear: "We don't fear complexity—we invest in solving it."

👉THE UNIVERSAL TRUTHS ( THESE WORK WITH EVERYONE)

Regardless of persona, three principles cut across every technician type:

1. Protect their time. "We protect your time with clean dispatching, parts staging, and real approvals. Diagnosis is sold and paid. No free figuring."

2. No-blame comebacks. "We do root-cause reviews, not scapegoating. If the system failed, the system gets fixed."

3. Proof over promises. Replace vague lines with specifics. Instead of "great culture," say "clear workflow, mutual respect, real standards." Instead of "competitive pay," explain how you handle diag time and downtime. Instead of "fast-paced," say "busy shop with clean process—not chaos."

🚨YOUR ACTION STEP🚨

Here's your assignment for next week:

Pick one technician on your team. Just one.

Before your next conversation with them, ask yourself:

Which of these six types are they closest to?
What are they really scanning for when I talk?
What's the one thing they need to hear from me?

Then say that thing. Directly. Clearly. Without filler.

Watch what happens.

The tech you've been struggling to connect with might suddenly become your easiest conversation—because for the first time, you're actually talking to them.

Not the technician in your head.

P.S. Most communication problems aren't communication problems. They're recognition problems. When your tech feels seen—truly understood—they don't need you to be perfect. They need you to be accurate.

That's the difference between a boss and a leader.

6:46

0 comments