Dead Horse finally kicked???-Preppy
I plan on this being my last post on Antonio’s recent preppy vs Ivy League vs Traditional post:
The use of the word preppy and its connotations vary greatly based upon the decade one was in High School.
For me, as a product of the sarcastic 1970’s- we welcomed basically anything to replace the dorky disco doubleknit disaster of the decade. By my Junior year in high school my Quiana shirts had been replaced with Gant rugby shirts and my bell bottoms were replaced by cotton poly blend Berle khakis with cuffs. The Preppy Handbook was not to show up for another 5-6 years so that word was unbeknown to me. As clothing styles happily returned to its pre polyester madness, the fashion world was turned on its head as feathered bangs on dudes, high heeled shoes and giant combs sticking out of guys pockets to maintain their zipperhead parts gave way to a rush toward natural fabrics, polo shirts, OCBDs etc . Yet still, I never had heard of the word preppy. By my Junior/Senior year in college-what was produced as another satirical parody along the lines of the popular Mad Magazine and National Lampoon magazine and similar sardonic movies like Animal House, Stripes, Caddy Shack, etc, (The Preppy Handbook) morphed from a joke to a Bible. We had a few in the store and would read them to each other laughing our tails off. Then the insanity began. Since we were named in the book people flocked to our stores to get their copy. We sold crates full at the store and being on commission learned to answer all kinds of goofy questions as though we were some kind of sartorial clerics.
It wasn’t until I joined this community almost three years ago that I realized guys younger than I by 10 years and longer had grown up with the term as part of their lexicon with an entirely different relationship to it than I. I also surmised that after my high school and college experience, for younger guys, preps were reduced down to just another clique like goths, and jocks, and normals etc.
To me clothings that had permanent style (CTM) is more regional than anything else:
British country ( tweeds tattersalls Barbours, wool club ties), East Coast (NE Ivy influenced more subtle colors; SE Ivy and SEC and Mid Atlantic conference influenced = brighter colored think seersucker and white bucks); West Coast (NW Woolrich, Filson, ~Pendleton; SW surfer shorts, open collars, light weight woolens); Mid West (Chicago large muted plaid, heavy padded shoulder high quality like Oxxford suits) and last not least the entire western influence ( boots, western yoke shirts, cowboy hats, Native American belts, bracelets, bold coats w whip stitching)
All of this - I would view as Classic Timeless Menswear. The terms like Preppy, and Old Money candidly make no sense to me unless one is wearing a costume.
Today’s “preppy” is so over the top it looks almost like a costume to me. J Press whose lookbooks just a year or two ago were classic examples of their CTM with an Ivy League twist they have displayed for over 100 years are now ballcaps with rugby shirts under a tweed. This fall is not quite as bad as last years but still
I get it when someone is putting overstatement on a mannequin in a window to sell specific items. It’s a completely different thing to my eyes when it’s in a catalog. Catalogs with live models to me depict what and how one is to wear the stores’s clothing. I agree with Antonio regarding preppy elements, stick to 2 elements but never 5 is a good rule of thumb. But these examples below are a bit shocking. Here again is an attempt to reduce Classic Timeless Menswear elements to merely another fashion exercise for the coming season. I mean, I get it if it’s a fun party like a tailgate or a regatta etc but….🤦
23
37 comments
Brian McGuire
9
Dead Horse finally kicked???-Preppy
Real Men Real Style Community
Leverage style to earn more money and build unshakeable confidence. This is a community for professional men serious about self-improvement.
Leaderboard (30-day)
1
+3008
2
+2282
3
+1648
4
+1559
5
+1418
Powered by