Hey guys,
With Christmas approaching, many of your orders will be gifts, so customers may be more anxious about delivery dates and quicker to get in touch when something goes wrong. If this is your first Christmas selling posters, knowing how to handle those messages can make things a little less stressful.
I’ve put together this guide to walk through the options available to you, how Etsy Purchase Protection may help, and some common situations you might face. There are also example replies you can adapt to your own customers. Although Christmas is the focus, many of these situations can happen throughout the year, so you can refer back to this guide whenever you need it.
Before promising a refund or replacement, take a moment to check the order and understand the issue. A delayed parcel, a damaged print and a customer who ordered the wrong size can each need a different approach.
You won’t always have an immediate answer, and that’s fine. Acknowledge the concern, explain what you’re checking and let the customer know when they’ll hear from you again. Then follow through, even if you’re still waiting for an update.
❗DISCLAIMER
There’s quite a bit of information here, so reading it is completely optional. You can work through it at your own pace or save it to refer back to whenever a customer issue comes up. Hopefully it’ll make those situations a little easier to handle!
▶ WHAT OPTIONS DO YOU HAVE?
Depending on what has happened, you may have several ways to resolve an issue. We’ll refer to these letters in the scenarios below, and sometimes use more than one option together.
Ⓐ Investigate and keep the customer updated
Check the order details, tracking and any photos the customer has provided. Compare what they ordered with what they received, and contact PrintShrimp if you need help investigating. PrintShrimp handles communication with the carrier on your behalf.
Let the customer know what you’re checking and when you’ll update them. If you’re still waiting for an answer by that time, send a quick update anyway.
Ⓑ Arrange a free replacement through PrintShrimp
PrintShrimp offers free replacements for damaged orders, incorrect orders, late orders and parcels confirmed lost in transit.
For damaged or incorrect items, gather a clear photo showing the issue and a photo of the shipping label. If damage is reported, request a photo of the packaging too. Include the order number when reporting the issue.
For late or lost parcels, contact PrintShrimp to confirm eligibility and arrange the replacement. PrintShrimp handles any carrier investigation on your behalf.
Orders marked as delivered by the carrier and missed deliveries returned to sender fall outside this free replacement coverage. For returned parcels, contact PrintShrimp to confirm the options available for the individual order.
Ⓒ Help the customer request an Etsy review
If an unresolved issue appears eligible for Etsy Purchase Protection, explain how the customer can ask Etsy to review it. Continue helping them and provide any evidence Etsy requests.
Etsy decides whether the order qualifies and who covers the refund, so explain the process without promising a particular outcome. Etsy Ⓓ Arrange a refund, return or exchange
You may need to resolve the issue directly through a refund, return or exchange, depending on what happened, the customer’s legal rights and your shop policies.
UK and EU customers generally have a 14-day right to withdraw from an online purchase without giving a reason. They must notify you within 14 days of receiving the item, then have a further 14 days to return it. This legal right takes precedence over your shop’s return policy, including a “no returns” policy.
Exceptions include genuinely personalised items or goods made to the customer’s specifications. A standard poster printed after purchase does not automatically qualify for that exemption.
For a change-of-mind return, the customer can generally be responsible for return postage if you clearly informed them before purchase. Refunds must include the original standard delivery charge where one was paid. Faulty or incorrectly supplied items have separate consumer protections.
Explain the return address, postage arrangements and refund process clearly.
Ⓔ Offer a goodwill solution
Where you have discretion, you could offer a partial refund if the customer is happy to keep the item, a discounted replacement or another agreed solution.
Explain exactly what you’re offering and get the customer’s agreement. Keep any goodwill offer independent of requests to change or remove a review.
❓How Etsy Purchase Protection fits in
Etsy Purchase Protection can help with qualifying orders that never arrive, arrive damaged, arrive significantly different from the listing, or arrive seven or more days after the maximum estimated delivery date shown at checkout.
The customer first needs to send a Help with Order request. If the issue remains unresolved after 48 hours and the order meets the timing requirements, they can ask Etsy to step in. For non-delivery cases, at least seven days must have passed since the maximum estimated delivery date.
For eligible seller protection, Etsy currently covers up to US$250 of the refund, including shipping and taxes. This can apply even when the order total is higher, with the seller responsible for the remaining amount. Etsy’s seller coverage for damage is limited to the first eligible damage case each calendar year. (Purchase protection) To qualify, sellers need to meet the full eligibility requirements. These include dispatching on time, providing valid tracking or an eligible Etsy postage label, using accurate listing and dispatch information, shipping to the address on the order, and responding to Help with Order requests within 48 hours. (Seller handbook) Check eligibility before advising a customer to open a case. If you issue a refund yourself, treat it as a seller-funded refund unless reimbursement has been confirmed. Etsy-funded refunds are handled through Etsy’s case process.
▶ COMMON SCENARIOS AND HOW TO HANDLE THEM
The options below refer to section two. Depending on what you find, you might start with Ⓐ and then move to Ⓑ, Ⓒ, Ⓓ or Ⓔ. The example replies are starting points, so adjust them to reflect the customer’s order and what you can offer.
1. “My order hasn’t arrived and the tracking hasn’t moved.”
- Options that may apply — Ⓐ, Ⓑ, Ⓒ or Ⓓ
Start with Ⓐ. Check the tracking, dispatch date and estimated delivery window, then report the issue to us. We’ll investigate with the carrier on your behalf.
We offer free replacements for eligible late orders and parcels confirmed lost in transit, so Ⓑ may resolve the issue. Confirm eligibility with us and check that the customer still wants a replacement.
If the customer wants a refund, consider Ⓒ or Ⓓ, depending on Etsy eligibility and their rights. Keep them informed while the investigation continues.
✉ Example reply
Hi [name], thanks for letting me know. I’ve checked the tracking and can see the last update was on [date]. I’ve raised this with my fulfilment partner so they can investigate with the carrier. I’ll update you as soon as I have an answer.
2. “Tracking says delivered, but I haven’t received anything.”
- Options that may apply — Ⓐ, then Ⓒ
Start with Ⓐ. Check any delivery photograph, safe-place information and the address on the order. Ask the customer to check the location shown and whether someone else at the address accepted it.
If the parcel is still missing, contact us with the details so we can investigate. Orders marked delivered fall outside our free replacement coverage.
If the issue remains unresolved, use Ⓒ to guide the customer through Etsy’s Purchase Protection process. Etsy can cover eligible claims, with the outcome subject to its review.
✉ Example reply
Hi [name], I’m sorry you haven’t been able to find your parcel. The tracking shows it was delivered on [date] to [delivery detail, if available]. Could you check [specific location] and whether anyone else at the address or a neighbour accepted it? If it’s still missing, let me know so I can look into it further and help you request a review through Etsy’s Purchase Protection programme.
3. “My poster or frame arrived damaged.”
- Options that may apply — Ⓐ and Ⓑ, or Ⓒ
Use Ⓐ and Ⓑ together if the customer wants a replacement. Request clear photos showing the damage, the packaging and the shipping label, then report the order to us.
If the customer has thrown away the packaging or label, let us know so we can confirm what evidence we can accept.
If the customer wants a refund, Ⓒ may apply. Etsy may cover a seller’s first eligible damage case per calendar year, January to December. Check whether that allowance has already been used and whether the order meets the other protection requirements before directing the customer through the process.
✉ Example reply
Hi [name], I’m sorry your order arrived damaged. Could you please send me a clear photo of the damage, a photo of the packaging and a photo of the shipping label? These will help me arrange a free replacement. Please also let me know if you need it by a particular date so I can check the timing.
4. “You sent the wrong item, or part of my order is missing.”
- Options that may apply — Ⓐ and Ⓑ
Start with Ⓐ. Compare what the customer ordered with what they received. If part of the order is missing, check whether it is arriving in a separate package.
Ask for photos showing what arrived, the packaging and the shipping label, then report the issue to us. We’ll investigate and arrange a free replacement for a confirmed incorrect or incomplete order.
✉ Example reply
Hi [name], I’m sorry there’s an issue with your order. Could you send me photos showing what you received and the shipping label? I’ll check these against your order and raise this with my fulfilment partner. I’ll be in touch as soon as I have an update.
5. “The artwork is cut off.”
- Options that may apply — Ⓐ, Ⓑ or Ⓓ
Start with Ⓐ. Compare the customer’s photo with the file submitted for that specific size and the listing images. Check whether the missing detail is visible in the submitted file, whether the aspect ratio was correct and whether a frame is covering the edges.
If the submitted file was correct and the artwork was cropped incorrectly during production, report it to us so we can investigate and arrange Ⓑ for a confirmed printing error.
If the cropping came from your uploaded file, correct the artwork and contact us before arranging another print. Confirm any replacement cost with us. Ⓓ may apply if you need to arrange a seller-funded replacement, exchange or refund.
✉ Example reply
Hi [name], thanks for bringing this to my attention. Could you send me a clear photo showing where the artwork is cut off, including the edges of the print? I’ll compare it with the file submitted for your order and check what happened. I’ll get back to you as soon as I have more information.
6. “This isn’t what I expected.”
This could include expecting a frame, an original painting, thicker paper, a different finish or brighter colours.
- Options that may apply — Ⓐ, Ⓑ, Ⓒ, Ⓓ or Ⓔ
Start with Ⓐ to establish what disappointed the customer. Compare the item received with the listing photographs, description and selected variation.
If you suspect a printing or fulfilment error, send us the order details and relevant photos. We’ll investigate, and Ⓑ can apply if we confirm an error covered by our free replacement policy.
If the listing misrepresented the product, consider Ⓓ. If a dispute about the listing’s accuracy remains unresolved, Ⓒ may apply, subject to Etsy’s eligibility requirements.
Where the item matches the listing, check applicable return rights and your shop policies under Ⓓ. You can also consider Ⓔ if there is a goodwill solution you are comfortable offering.
✉ Example reply
Hi [name], I’m sorry the item wasn’t what you expected. Could you tell me a little more about the issue and send a clear photo showing what you received? I’ll compare it with your order and the listing, and check with my fulfilment partner if needed. I’ll be in touch as soon as I have an update.
7. “I ordered the wrong size, it doesn’t fit my frame, or I’ve changed my mind.”
Options that may apply — Ⓐ, Ⓓ or Ⓔ
Start with Ⓐ. Check the size selected at checkout and confirm that the customer received what they ordered. If the print doesn’t fit their frame, ask for the measurements of the print and the frame opening.
If the correct size was supplied, consider Ⓓ according to the customer’s applicable return rights and your shop policies. Explain any return or exchange arrangements clearly before the customer sends anything back.
You can also consider Ⓔ, such as a discounted print in their preferred size, if that suits both you and the customer.
✉ Example reply
Hi [name], thanks for getting in touch. Your order was for [size]. Could you confirm the measurements of the print you received and the opening inside your frame? That will help me understand the fit issue and explain the options available.
✉ For a change of mind
Hi [name], thanks for letting me know. [Explain the return or exchange options applicable to this order, including any deadline, return instructions and postage costs.]
8. “I entered the wrong address, it was delivered to a different address, I missed the delivery, or didn’t collect the parcel.”
- Options that may apply — Ⓐ, Ⓑ, Ⓒ, Ⓓ or Ⓔ
Start with Ⓐ. Check the address on the Etsy order, the tracking and any delivery photograph. Establish whether the buyer entered an incorrect address, the parcel was sent to a different address, or the carrier delivered it to the wrong location.
Contact us with the order details and any supporting evidence. We’ll investigate with the carrier on your behalf.
Ⓑ may apply depending on the circumstances. We’ll confirm whether a free replacement is available for the individual case.
Ⓒ may apply if the unresolved issue qualifies for Etsy Purchase Protection. Eligibility depends on what caused the delivery problem and whether the order meets Etsy’s requirements. Non-delivery caused by buyer delay is generally excluded, and seller protection requires dispatch to the address on the Etsy order.
Consider Ⓓ or Ⓔ according to the customer’s rights, your shop policies and any alternative you’re willing to offer.
✉ Example reply
Hi [name], thanks for letting me know. Could you confirm the full delivery address, including the postcode or post code? If the delivery photograph shows somewhere you don’t recognise, please let me know too. I’ll check the details with my fulfilment partner and be in touch as soon as I have an update.
9. “I didn’t realise this was AI artwork.”
- Options that may apply — Ⓐ and Ⓓ
Start with Ⓐ. Check what the listing disclosed at the time of purchase and whether the customer is raising any additional concern about the artwork.
If AI use was explained in the item description, politely point this out to the customer and acknowledge their preference.
Then work through Ⓓ, checking applicable return rights and your shop policies. Explain the return and refund arrangements clearly, including where to send the item and any applicable return postage costs.
✉ Example reply
Hi [name], I understand your concern. The item description explains that this artwork was created using AI-assisted techniques, although I appreciate that you may have missed this before ordering. [Explain the return and refund options applicable to this order, including return instructions and any applicable postage costs.]
!!! Only mention the disclosure if it was present when the customer purchased.
9. “I need this before Christmas.”
- Options that may apply — Ⓐ, Ⓑ, Ⓒ, Ⓓ or Ⓔ
Before purchase, use Ⓐ to explain the current delivery estimate for the product and destination. Check Tom’s Christmas 2026 - All You Need to Know! Post and avoid promising a date you cannot guarantee.
For a late, lost, damaged or incorrect order, contact us to investigate and consider Ⓑ. We can help you check replacement timing so you can establish whether the customer still wants it.
If it arrives after Christmas, compare its arrival with Etsy’s checkout estimate and any delivery commitment you made. (Ⓒ) Etsy’s qualifying late-delivery threshold is seven or more days beyond the maximum checkout estimate. Applicable cancellation or refund rights may also support Ⓓ. Etsy help If the recipient simply doesn’t like the gift, work through the usual return options.
✉ Example reply before purchase
Hi [name], thanks for checking! The current estimated delivery window for [product] to [destination] is [dates]. I can’t guarantee arrival by [date], so I wanted to make that clear before you order.
✉ Example reply when a gift order has a problem
Hi [name], I’m sorry this has happened, especially as it’s a Christmas gift. I’m checking [the delivery issue/replacement timing] with my fulfilment partner and will update you as soon as possible. Could you let me know the latest date you need it? That will help us work out which resolution suits your situation.
▶ FINAL THOUGHTS
Customer service can feel stressful, especially when someone is upset about a Christmas gift. Take a moment to check the facts before replying, acknowledge their concern and explain what you can do next. If you need help investigating an order, contact us with the order number and any relevant photos.
Keep your customer replies clear and focused. Customers need to know that you’re looking into the issue, what options are available and what happens next. Internal conversations, printing costs and the details of a supplier claim can usually stay behind the scenes. Be honest about what you know and share updates as you receive them.
Feel free to use the templates as a starting point and adapt them to the person you’re speaking to. A reply that addresses their particular concern will feel more reassuring than a generic message.
Sometimes a customer will still leave a poor review after you’ve tried to resolve the problem. Give yourself time to respond calmly, and remember that one difficult experience is part of a much longer history of serving your customers.
- Christmas order information
Although this guide focuses on Christmas, you can return to it throughout the year whenever a similar situation comes up.