Match #4 · Brotherhood Of Scent

Match #4

Match #4 in my 40-fragrance tournament was a contrast in styles. It paired #28 seed Givenchy Gentleman Original against #37 seed Montblanc Explorer Platinum.

Givenchy Gentleman Original (1974, 2024 created by Paul Léger) is an old-school classic built around honey, cinnamon, rose, patchouli, leather, oakmoss, and vetiver. It has a mature, confident character that feels timeless rather than dated.

Montblanc Explorer Platinum (2023, created by Bruno Jovanovic) takes the Explorer line in a fresher direction with violet leaves, clary sage, and cedarwood. It's clean, modern, and easy to wear, but for me it never quite matches the appeal of the original Explorer.

I like both fragrances, but this matchup had a clear winner. The Givenchy has more personality and gives me that classic, mature feeling I really enjoy. Explorer Platinum is pleasant, but I'd reach for the original Explorer every time. Givenchy Gentleman Original advances, while Montblanc Explorer Platinum drops into the loser's bracket.

10 comments

Match #4