It's tempting to clean out inactive members. Before you do, spend a week finding out why they went quiet. You might learn something more useful than a smaller member list. Step 1: Split them into two groups. Those who never posted, and those who used to be active. Step 2: Send each group a short, human message. For people who never posted: "Hi Maya, I noticed you joined a while back but haven't had a chance to jump in. Quick question: what were you hoping to find here? If something's missing, I'd love to know." For people who used to be active: "Hi Maya, you were a regular a while ago and I miss your comments. Did something change, or did the content stop being useful? Honest answers help me a lot." Step 3: Read the replies and sort them into reasons: too busy, couldn't find what they needed, content wasn't relevant, don't remember joining. Step 4: Fix the biggest reason. If most say they couldn't find anything, improve your pinned posts and your first-week plan. Step 5: After that, decide who to keep. Some people stay quiet but still read, and that's fine. Keep messages short, send them in small batches, and never use the same text for everyone. You'll usually get fewer replies than you'd like, but a handful of honest answers is worth more than guessing. What's the most common reason you think members go quiet in your community?