Possibly, but not necessarily from scratch. The issue for most skinny-fat guys isn't effort. It's that the training structure isn't optimised for their body type. Too much cardio, not enough resistance work, wrong rep ranges, no progressive overload — these are the common patterns. The guide and 4-week plan give you a framework built specifically around how your body responds. Whether you need a more wholesale reset or just some adjustments depends on what you're currently doing. If you're unsure, post your current routine in Discussion and I'll give you an honest assessment.

Neither really, but you do want to prioritise losing fat as opposed to packing on muscle. Standard bulk and cut cycles were designed for body types that respond differently to training and nutrition than yours does. Bulking makes skinny-fat guys softer. You don't gain muscle the way an already-lean guy does, you just add more fat to a soft frame. Aggressive cutting makes you smaller but still undefined so you lose muscle alongside fat and end up lighter but the same shape. The answer is a specific recomposition approach built around how your body actually works.

Honest answer: visible changes typically start showing around weeks 4-6 IF you're consistent. The scale will barely move and might even go up slightly early on. That's normal and not a bad sign, it usually means muscle is being built at the same time as fat loss. Progress shows in the mirror and how your clothes fit, not the number on the scale. Take progress photos every two weeks in the same lighting. Most people are surprised by what they see when they compare week 1 to week 6. Give it 8-12 weeks before making any judgements about whether it's working.

Yes, and skinny-fat guys are actually better positioned for this than most. It is by no means easy though - and requires some careful management. Your body composition at the starting point will likely make recomposition more effective than it would be for someone who is already lean or significantly overweight. The guide explains exactly why and how to make it work for your specific body type. The short version: your body has fat stores available to fuel muscle building while in a slight deficit. Most people can't take advantage of this the way you can.

Recomposition means building muscle and losing fat at the same time rather than doing them separately. Most standard fitness advice tells you to bulk first then cut.That approach works for certain body types but tends to make the skinny-fat situation worse, not better. Recomposition is the correct starting point for where you are right now. SFS is built entirely around making this work specifically for the skinny-fat body type.