Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More
8 contributions to Lead Gen Secrets
🟡🟡0.3% human reply rate 638 contacted🟡🟡
Yo! I launched my first cold email campaign on the 13th after spending the last 4+ months building automations and warming up my mailboxes. (Waste of time don't do this) I'm using Consulti.ai for leads, Inbox Insiders for my 27 mailboxes, and Jay's 4-email sequence (days 1, 3, 7, and 12). Currently adding 203 new businesses a day, which should work out to roughly 810 emails/day once all the follow-ups are running. So far I've reached out to 638 business, sent 1,000 emails, and have a 0.3% human reply rate. 2 replies and neither was positve lol. I ran an inbox placement test through Instantly and got 97.7%, so that seems pretty healthy. I've also got open and click tracking disabled. I'm offering AI phone receptionists to blue-collar trades like HVAC, plumbing, electrical, etc. Which I feel like it's a very saturated industry although I believe there is enough in the pot for everyone! For anyone who's been doing this successfully, what would you look at first? The copy, the offer, or the targeting? First time doing cold email, so I'm genuinely trying to figure this out. Appreciate any honest feedback!
🟡🟡0.3% human reply rate 638 contacted🟡🟡
0 likes • 12h
@Zubair Aqeel Thanks Zubair! Ill try that out!
0 likes • 12h
@Ahmed Mohamed Thanks for the detialed insight Ahmed I appreicate it. This gave me a different perspective and helped a lot!
15 mailboxes need 3,300 new leads a month: the 5 numbers I'd work out before picking a sending plan
A question that keeps coming up here: which plan, how many mailboxes, how many domains. Most people pick the plan first and find out later that the list can't keep up with the mailboxes, or the other way round. Here's a simple way to size it before paying for anything: 1. Start from leads, not mailboxes. How many verified leads can you actually source each month? 2. Multiply by the emails in your sequence. Mine is 3 emails over 7 days, so every lead costs 3 sends. 3. Divide by your sending days in the month. That's your emails per day. 4. Divide that by sends per mailbox per day and round up. I keep mine at 30. That's your mailboxes. 5. Run it backwards too. Mailboxes x daily sends x sending days, divided by emails per lead, is how many new leads they need every month to stay busy. Screenshot is the simple sheet. The top block is my setup: 15 mailboxes at 30 a day is 450 emails a day. If they send 22 days a month on a 3 email sequence, that's about 3,300 new leads a month just to keep them full. The bottom block is a sample: someone who can source 1,000 verified leads a month needs 5 mailboxes, not 15. How many new leads a month are you feeding your mailboxes right now?
15 mailboxes need 3,300 new leads a month: the 5 numbers I'd work out before picking a sending plan
2 likes • 18h
This is actually a really useful way to look at it. I'm running around 24 mailboxes myself, and balancing new leads with follow-up volume has been interesting. One thing I'm curious about: are you accounting for leads who reply and exit the sequence early? Because that could change the actual number of new leads needed each month.
Explee
I have been seeing a lot of social media posts about explee. It’s a saas that basically does everything a cold email lead gen service does for a fraction of the price. Has anyone tried this and does it really work? Should people offering or intending to start offering lead gen services be worried? @Jay Feldman
2 likes • 19h
I haven't personally tested Explee yet, but I definitely think agencies should be paying attention to tools like this. If your entire service is finding leads, generating AI copy, and sending emails, I think that part of the industry is becoming increasingly competitive. But there's a difference between automating outreach and consistently generating qualified appointments that turn into paying customers. I'm running outbound myself, and I'm realizing that the real challenge isn't sending emails. It's figuring out why campaigns aren't converting and knowing what to change. Has anyone actually tested Explee for 30–60 days? I'd be interested in seeing the cost per qualified appointment rather than just the cost per email.
Apollo gives me almost nothing for local niche campaigns. How are you sourcing emails?
Hey everyone, I’m running cold email campaigns for a very specific niche in a specific region (small local businesses in one country/state). The problem is that Apollo returns very few results, and most of the contacts it does have are outdated or missing emails. Here’s what I’ve tried so far: - Apollo filters (by industry, location, and keywords) - Apify email scraping from the company’s website URL. What I’d love to hear from you: 1. Where do you source emails for local, niche-specific lists when Apollo, ZoomInfo, and similar databases don’t have enough coverage? 2. How do you use Apify effectively for lead gen? Which actors are worth using (Google Maps scrapers, contact info scrapers, etc.), and how do you chain them into a full workflow, from finding businesses to getting website URLs to extracting emails? 3. How do you find the owner’s email, not just info@ or contact@ addresses? Any good workflow for finding the owner’s name and then the email pattern? 4. Which email finders and verifiers have given you the best hit rate for small businesses (Hunter, Snov, Findymail, etc.)? 5. Any other sources (directories, licensing databases, Facebook pages, Yelp, associations) that work well for local niches? If you have a workflow or stack that works, even a rough outline, I’d really appreciate it. Happy to share my results once I test the suggestions. 🙏
2 likes • 19h
I've been sourcing owners of smaller HVAC businesses myself, so I definitely understand the challenge with local niches. I'd recommend checking out Consulti.ai. They have a dedicated local-business database, along with email finding and verification tools. This is Jay's platform. You can sign up here: https://consulti.ai?via=sam-chicquen If you're also looking for cold email infrastructure, I'd check out Inbox Insiders. They handle the domains, mailboxes, and warm-up. Also Jays platform You can sign up here: https://inboxinsiders.io?via=sam Out of curiosity, what niche and region are you targeting? Depending on the industry, there might be a few other ways to find the actual business owners.
450 cold emails on day one, first call booked 2 minutes after Email 1
Most advice says expect nothing in the first few weeks. On Nov 7 I launched and a CEO of a 40-year-old web design agency replied "Thursday will work" 2 minutes after Email 1 went out. One call doesn't prove a campaign, but here's the setup behind it: 1. 3 niches x 2 offers = 6 campaigns, split 50/50, so the data picks the offer and I don't have to guess. 2. 15 mailboxes warmed about 25 days at 100% health, then 30 emails a day each. That's the 450. 3. A personal first line for every lead, written from their own website. 4. Plain text, no links, no tracking. Email 2 on day 3 opens with the offer itself, Email 3 on day 7 is a lower friction ask. The part that went wrong: 6 to 11% bounces on day one. Instantly's verifier flagged 300 of my 1,468 leads as bad, even though the scraper had marked them validated. They're gone now and every new lead gets verified before upload. Screenshot is the simple sheet with the real day one numbers. What did your first day of sending look like?
450 cold emails on day one, first call booked 2 minutes after Email 1
3 likes • 19h
Haha, my first day definitely didn't look like a call booked in 2 minutes 😂 I'm running outbound through Instantly as well, currently using around 24 mailboxes. My biggest challenge right now is figuring out whether low reply rates are coming from deliverability, the offer, or the targeting. That 6–11% bounce rate caught my attention though, especially with supposedly verified leads. Curious, are you doing any actual inbox placement testing, or are you relying primarily on Instantly's warm-up health scores?
1-8 of 8
Sam Chicquen
2
2 points to level up
@sam-chicquen-6810
I turn AI into money printers for businesses

Active 10h ago
Joined May 23, 2026
Powered by