Leading Through Disruption: A CDMO's Guide to Communicating the Impact of AI on Search
Organic traffic is declining. Referral traffic from large language models (LLMs) is a fraction of what has been lost. Click-through rates are in freefall. As a marketing leader, you see the data, you understand the tectonic shifts occurring in search, and you know this is not a temporary anomaly. The temptation to shield the executive team from this uncertainty is understandable, but it is a strategic error. Now is not the time for avoidance; it is the time for leadership.
This is your moment to control the narrative, educate your C-suite, and demonstrate that you are not just reacting to change but actively shaping your organization's response to it. This article provides a comprehensive framework for having this critical conversation, moving beyond tactical SEO updates to a strategic discussion about business impact, resource allocation, and the future of customer acquisition.
Seizing the Narrative: A Data-Driven Approach to Executive Communication
Your first objective is to present the unvarnished truth, grounded in data that speaks the language of the C-suite: revenue, leads, and market position. Do not wait for the board to assign an analyst to investigate performance dips. Lead with facts, not fear, and frame the conversation as a strategic briefing, not a crisis meeting.
Quantify the Business Impact: Begin with a clear-eyed assessment of what has changed. Present year-over-year data on organic traffic, key conversion events, and, most importantly, revenue. This immediately ties the discussion to business outcomes, not vanity metrics. Acknowledge performance declines directly—if organic traffic is down 30%, own it. This transparency builds credibility and sets the stage for a productive, solution-oriented discussion.
Isolate the Cause: Use data to distinguish between a soft market and a fundamental ecosystem shift. Export click-through rate (CTR) data from Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools, isolating queries and URLs that have experienced the sharpest declines. Cross-reference these with SERPs now displaying AI Overviews. If your competitors are facing the same headwinds, as indicated by their own traffic estimates and keyword rankings, it reinforces that this is a market-wide disruption, not an internal failure.
Contextualize the Shift: Broaden the aperture beyond your own analytics. Explain the critical events driving this change, from the rise of conversational AI like ChatGPT and Gemini to the rollout of Google's AI Overviews, which have been reported to reduce organic CTR by as much as 61% in some cases. This demonstrates that you have a command of the external landscape and are not operating in a vacuum.
The Strategic Response: A Framework for Adaptation and Growth
Once you have established the reality of the situation, the conversation must pivot from diagnosis to solution. This is where you demonstrate that you are thinking three steps ahead. Present a clear, actionable plan that shows your team is not just managing a decline but reorienting for a new era of growth.
Expand the Definition of Visibility: The goal is no longer just to rank, but to be mentioned. If customers are getting answers without clicking, your brand must be present in those answers. This requires a strategic pivot to increase your brand's presence in AI-generated responses and emerging discovery platforms. Outline initiatives to track the questions that matter most to your buyers, understand where your brand appears today, and prioritize content, digital PR, and partnerships to increase your share of voice in this new, clickless environment.
Evolve Content Strategy from Keywords to Entities: LLMs reward brands with deep, consistent, and authoritative coverage of a topic. Explain that this is the next evolution of content marketing, requiring a shift from a keyword-centric approach to an entity-based one. This impacts not just what you publish, but how you structure content and collaborate with internal subject matter experts, product teams, and PR to build unassailable authority over time.
Redefine the Measurement Framework: Google organic traffic is no longer the single source of truth. Propose a new, expanded measurement framework that accounts for AI surfaces, social discovery, and referral ecosystems. This new dashboard must track not just traffic and conversions, but also brand mentions in AI summaries, share of voice across platforms, and the assisted impact of content that may not generate a direct click but influences a future purchase.
Securing Buy-In: The Resource and Alignment Imperative
A strategy without resources is merely a hallucination. Having presented the problem and the solution, you must now be explicit about what you need to execute your plan. This is not a request for a blank check, but a business case for targeted investment in the capabilities required to win.
Reset Baselines and Expectations: Make it clear that AI Overviews are a permanent shift, not a temporary test. This necessitates a full reset of traffic baselines, forecasts, and performance goals. The organization must accept that last year's dashboards are no longer relevant and that success in the AI era will be measured differently. Secure agreement on realistic timeframes and leading indicators that will be tracked as you navigate this transition.
Secure Executive Mandate for Long-Term Brand Building: The pursuit of AI visibility requires a commitment to initiatives that will not pay off in the current quarter. You need executive buy-in to prioritize long-term brand building alongside short-term performance metrics. This means updating KPIs so your team is not penalized for investing in assets that compound over time, such as building a deep content library or cultivating high-authority partnerships.
Obtain Budget Flexibility for Innovation: A portion of the marketing budget must be earmarked for experimentation. This includes investing in new AI visibility tools, implementing advanced structured data, developing interactive content formats, and funding partnerships that increase your odds of being cited in AI answers. Frame this not as a cost, but as a strategic investment in learning and adaptation.
Drive Cross-Functional Collaboration: SEO can no longer operate in a silo. You need a mandate to drive collaboration with analytics to build new dashboards, PR to prioritize placements that feed AI systems, and product and content teams to align roadmaps with the topics and entities that matter most. Without this alignment, your efforts will be fragmented and your data will be untrustworthy.
Conclusion: From SEO Manager to Business Leader
By initiating this conversation, you are fundamentally changing your role from that of a channel manager to a strategic business leader. You are not just reporting on SEO; you are guiding your organization through a period of profound disruption. This is your opportunity to demonstrate foresight, build trust with your executive team, and secure the resources necessary to future-proof your company's ability to earn visibility, trust, and revenue in a radically new environment. The game has changed, and by leading this conversation, you are ensuring your organization adapts and wins.
1
0 comments
Leading Through Disruption: A CDMO's Guide to Communicating the Impact of AI on Search
skool.com/seo-success-academy
Welcome to SEO Success Academy – the ultimate destination for business owners, digital marketers and agencies to master the art and science of SEO.
Leaderboard (30-day)
1
+2
Powered by