5d (edited) • World News
The Noma Fallout: Is the "Old Guard" Dying, or Is the System Broken?
The culinary world is shaking this week with the resignation of René Redzepi. While the headlines focus on the 'toxicity' at Noma, as chefs and food lovers, we need to look deeper at what this means for the future of our kitchens.
1. Discipline is Not Abuse
There is a massive difference between a toxic environment and a disciplined one. The 'Brigade' system was created for order, precision, and speed; it’s a military structure because high-end service is a battle against time. You can’t achieve Michelin-level results without respect for the Chef’s vision and the years of experience behind it.
2. The 'TV Effect' vs. Reality
We are seeing a generation of newcomers influenced by Hell’s Kitchen and MasterChef. They arrive with 'flashy' techniques but often lack the fundamental speed, precision, and discipline required. A kitchen isn't a stage for ego; it’s a place where the ingredient is king and the clock is the judge.
3. The Mental Game
To achieve high-end results without 'toxic' pressure, we need two things:
- Better Selection: Not everyone is built for the 'heat' of a high-pressure kitchen. That isn't an insult; it’s a reality of the trade.
- Mental Fortitude: We need to train staff not just to chop, but to handle the mental demands of service without breaking.
4. The Economics of the Plate
The line between 'hard work' and 'exploitation' often comes down to the check. When restaurants try to keep prices low while revenue is thin, the pressure falls on the staff. Using 'We are a family' as a way to trigger guilt for unpaid hours is where the industry fails its people. Hard work deserves fair pay. Plain and simple.
My take? Excellence doesn't require abuse, but it does require a level of discipline that social media doesn't show you. We can change the attitude of the leader, but we shouldn't discard the order of the kitchen.
What do you think? Is the 'Brigade' system outdated, or do we just need better leaders and better-prepared staff? Let’s discuss below. 👇
3
0 comments
The Noma Fallout: Is the "Old Guard" Dying, or Is the System Broken?
powered by
skool.com/kitchen-passport-1509
From the world's kitchen's to the family tabel.
Learn global chef secrets and professional techniques, adapted for quick and flavourful family meals
Suggested communities
Powered by