🍕 What the Recipe Doesn’t Tell You About Topping a Pizza

⭐

So I made the Sourdough Neapolitan today and I wanna walk you through what I learned, because the recipe gets you 80 percent of the way there, but the last 20 percent is where home pizza usually falls apart.

Here’s what nobody tells you.

Less sauce than you think. I spread mine in a thin layer with the back of a spoon, leaving a good half-inch of bare dough at the rim. You should still see flecks of dough through the sauce in places. Too much sauce is the number one reason a home pizza comes out soggy in the middle. Light is the word.

Order matters. This is the part most folks get wrong. Sauce, then cheese (a moderate layer, not a snowdrift), then your heaviest toppings, then your lightest. Mine went: sauce, mozzarella, sausage, mushrooms sliced thin, pepperoni on top, a few rings of red onion to finish. Pepperoni on top is the move. It crisps at the edges and the oil renders down through everything below it. That’s the flavor you’ve been missing.

Don’t crowd it. I stopped myself twice from adding more. Every topping needs a little space around it. Crowded pizza means soggy pizza, every time. You should see cheese peeking through.

Mushrooms thin, and not too many. They put off water. A modest scatter of thin slices is plenty. Pile them on and you’ll have puddles.

Basil goes on AFTER. Not before. Fresh basil burns to black in a hot oven and turns bitter. Bake the pizza, pull it out, then tear the leaves by hand and scatter them on the hot top. The residual heat wakes them up and you get that bright green color and real basil flavor. That’s how the good places do it.

Now the move that took mine over the top. Before launching, I painted the bare rim with olive oil using my fingers, then gave it a pinch of flaky salt. That’s it. Three seconds of work. But that’s the difference between a pale, bland crust people leave on the plate and a rim that browns, blisters, and tastes like something. Salt on the rim makes you eat the whole slice.

And the bake. Oven cranked as high as it’ll go, 500 or higher, with the stone or steel saturated for a full 45 minutes minimum. Not 10 minutes. The stone needs to be storing heat, not just warm on top. Pizza bakes from the bottom up.

I pulled mine when the cheese was bubbly with golden spots, the rim was deep brown with real char on it, and the bottom was crisp. Rested it two minutes before slicing so the cheese set and didn’t slide off.

The journey was: bare stretched dough

→ light sauce

→ cheese

→ sausage and mushrooms

→ pepperoni

→ red onion

→ painted rim with oil and salt

→ bake

→ torn basil on top

→ rest

→ slice.

If you’re baking pizza this weekend, take the half hour. Paint that rim. Order your toppings. Hold the basil until the end. That’s the difference between making a pizza and making a pizza.

🍕 Sourdough Neapolitan recipe: https://skoo.ly/sd-neapolitan

Perfection is not required. Progress is.

Henry ⭐🔥

47 comments