Dusty, now you're speaking my language. This is exactly the kind of question that turns a recipe follower into a baker. Here's the thing. It's not just the water, though you're not wrong that water is part of it. Three things drive that hard, chewy baguette versus a soft French loaf. First, crust and gluten. A lean dough baked hot with steam sets up a thin, crackly crust and a chewy interior. That chew comes from strong gluten structure in a lean formula, just flour, water, salt, and yeast. There's nothing in there to soften it, so it stays firm and toothsome. Second, formula. A softer French loaf usually has something extra working in the background, a little fat, milk, or a different flour. Fat coats the gluten strands and tenderizes them. That's what gives you the pillowy crumb your family's taking to church tonight. Third, hydration, and this is where your instinct is right. More water gives you a more open, moist, tender crumb. So yes, the higher water content softened things up. It just works alongside the crust and the formula, not on its own. Now, about that sloppy dough. You said it yourself, you can cut the air with a knife down there right now. That humidity matters. Your flour pulls moisture straight out of the air before you ever add water, so the dough runs wetter and stickier than the recipe reads on paper. Next time, hold back 15 or 20 grams of water at the start and add it only if the dough asks for it. Same bread, less slop. And that goal you mentioned, baking without looking up recipes? You're closer than you think. The day you stop reading water as a number and start reading it as a feel, you've crossed over.