How to Approach a Trademark Conflict When Another Brand Owns the Mark
When you discover that a competing brand already owns trademark rights in your target market, you are dealing with a territorial trademark conflict. Because trademark rights are jurisdiction-specific, you must follow a structured approach to determine whether expansion is possible and on what terms. Below is a step-by-step framework used by franchisors, global brands, and IP attorneys. 1. Determine the Type and Strength of the Other Party’s Trademark Rights Trademark conflicts are not all equal. Start by determining: Is the mark federally registered? - In the U.S., a USPTO federal registration gives nationwide priority. - In other countries, national registration gives strong exclusivity. Is it registered only regionally/state-by-state? - In the U.S., state-level registrations exist, but are much weaker than federal registrations. - In some countries (Canada, India, EU), federal registration is required and regional registration is limited. Is the owner using the trademark in commerce? - Non-use can weaken or void rights. - Many trademarks are abandoned after a few years. Why this matters:You may be able to prove: - The other party has not used the mark, - Has abandoned the mark, or - Only has limited jurisdictional rights. This can open the door to filing your own application or negotiating a coexistence agreement. 2. Conduct a Full Clearance Search (Not Just a USPTO Search) A true clearance search checks: - Federal USPTO database - State trademark databases - Common law use (websites, social media, business filings, retail presence) - Domain names - WIPO/International registries (if expanding globally) This creates a complete picture of real risk. A competitor may own a registration but: - Not use it consistently - Use it in an unrelated category - Operate in a geographic area where confusion is unlikely These facts matter when you negotiate or litigate. 3. Assess Your Options Based on the Risk Level Once you know the full story, there are five main strategic options: