Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More
178 contributions to Brotherhood Of Scent
FRAGRANCE MYTHS: FACT VS. FICTION
PART 19 MYTH: “If a fragrance is reformulated, the new version is always worse.” FICTION. This is one of those fragrance-community beliefs that gets repeated so often that people start treating it like a rule. Yes, reformulations happen. Ingredients can become restricted, materials can become harder or more expensive to source, regulations can change, and brands may decide to adjust a formula for any number of reasons. But reformulated does not automatically mean ruined. Sometimes a newer version may smell lighter, smoother, cleaner, less dense, or slightly different from an older bottle. Performance can change too. But different does not automatically mean worse. There are also times when the newer formula may actually be easier to wear, better balanced, or simply more appealing to someone who never smelled the older version. Another thing I keep in mind is that people are often comparing a brand-new bottle to an older bottle that has been sitting for years. Age, storage conditions, batch differences, and even your own memory of the fragrance can influence that comparison. And nostalgia is powerful. If someone wore the original version ten or fifteen years ago, they may be comparing the new bottle not only to the old fragrance, but also to the memories attached to it. For me, I don’t automatically dismiss a fragrance because somebody tells me it was reformulated. I want to smell the current version for myself. A reformulation can be different. It can even be weaker. But “reformulated”does not automatically mean “worse.”
0 likes • 6h
I often heard this idea, and currently I'm interested in a fragrance that has a 2025 version I like (YSL Y Le Parfum). But whoever speaks of it and reviews it say's thje 2021 version was much better 🤷Now, if I find a bottle (difficult) of the older version it will be at least 2-3 years old, couldn't that be already a problem (nowone knows the storage conditions, temo, humidity etc) ? And speaking of decants it's still more difficult to find old versions... I think i'll go with the new one and that's it. Another thing I thought reading your post, is that probably in new versions of historical fragrances, the brands adapt the new scents to the new habits and customs of society and of the majority of buyers. Especially famous fragrances are not remade for our superexperts in the Brotherhood, but to sell thousend or millions of bottles to the big public
So happy for fall
The temperature is in Texas have finally committed to being lower, and we’re once again getting consistent weather in the 50s and 60s. I’ve begun rotating out my sent wardrobe, removing citrus and freshies, and bringing Amber’s and spices and woody fragrances to the front. I feel like me again, and all of a sudden my wardrobe feels comfortable and familiar. Does anyone else feel this way? Is fall and winter your favorite season? What are your favorite fall fragrances?
3 likes • 8h
@L Gonzalez Thank you great idea, I like Iris and imagine it can smoothen the leather smell, will try it for sure !! With this name (extreme) I wouldn't have tried it !!
2 likes • 7h
@Stephen DeMent really thank's a lot this is a super list !! I wrote them down and will explore them slowly !! 🔝
One Thing Leads To Another, Again...
Went to drop off the doggy for his heart worm injection and needed to kill time. My co worker asked me to buy him D&G Light Blue EDP. So I went to downtown McAllen and stopped at Galeria Perfumes and got it. Looked at a couple of others including Supremacy Collector's Edition. Decided to walk around more and hit Gold Palace where I acquired Rayhaan Terra and Rasasi La Yuqawam. Continued down to Royal Perfumes and scored Hugo Boss Bottled Absolu. Decided to go back and pick up Collector's Edition as well. Due to the Mexican Revolution Holiday a couple of stores were too packed to enter. I have to stop picking up scents for others!
One Thing Leads To Another,  Again...
3 likes • 17h
I made it worse, I was not even buying something for others, I was just online looking for new scents to try, found and ordered 4 decants....and then a 100 ml bottle of a fragrance I loved testing it some weeks ago (Michael Kors Pour Homme Eau de Parfum)... oh but look....this is in special offer....oh look this too is in special offer...🤦‍♂️....I placed the order with 4 decants and 4 bottles (3 of which in blind buy)
2 likes • 8h
@Edgar Mertins I found it in a Notino discovery Set which I bought for other scents, and it was a real surprise, never heard of it, and it was the best fragrance in the packet
Your worst Blind Buy ? This was mine....
My greatest mistake, with a double error, happened last year !! Davidoff Cool Water was one of my favourite fragrances during my adolescence, just following Versace l'Homme and Drakkar Noir. Last year I was online looking for something new, and I found a very good offer for a 125ml Cool Water bottle (around 30$). Nostalgia for my youth immediately took over, and I bought the bottle with no hesitation...and unfortunately without information and further details of the flanker. It was called Intense, I just thought "Wow, an intense version of my original Cool Water"....what could go wrong ??? The moment I received the packet and sprayed was the moment I discovered Fragrantica Notes 😭 And I really felt stupid 🥶I was so disappointed, not only for the new fragrances I didn't love (it's not soo bad after all), but to have missed my Nostalgia Moment 🤣 Well I didn't lear to avoid blind buys, but at least I learned to study in detail what I buy befor purchasing it !! 😉 And what was your worst experience in blind buys ?
Your worst Blind Buy ? This was mine....
2 likes • 2d
@Steve Hawker Promise I won't try it
2 likes • 2d
@Mike Penzenik Caught 😅!! But I have the excuse of the disappointment of Cool Water Intense, insisting also with the Elixir would be asking for trouble !! 🤣
SOTD = YSL Y EDP Intense
This is a new acquisition. The opening is familiar but there is a similarity to CH Men Pasion to my nose. I know that Iris is not listed as a note but that's what I perceive. My co worker wanted to smell D&G Light Blue EDP so I brought it as he's interested in it. Thought my nose was playing tricks on me but the juniper and citrus smells similar to it as well. Projection is moderate/strong this first hour and a half wearing Y EDP Intense. This is the middle brother of the younger Y EDP and older Y Le Parfum 2021. Not as boisterous as Y EDP and not as mature as Le Parfum. Will update later with more thoughts.
SOTD = YSL Y EDP Intense
4 likes • 3d
I'll follow your later thoghts, really interested in this fragrance. Actually I’ve been mulling it over for a while, but I can’t figure out which flanker to buy. I looked a lot of reviews and one say Le Parfum, others Eau de Parfum (normal or intense) and someone prefers the freshness of the EDT 😱 .... what would you say ? Could it be a choice depending from the season I'll wear it ? I'm looking for a fragrance for the winter, in my (general) idea Le Parfum fits better, but following the notes I think i'll prefer EDP...as you see I'm quite confused 🤣
1 like • 2d
@L Gonzalez Wow goes directly to TOP10 😉
1-10 of 178
Massimiliano Hajny
6
729 points to level up
@massimiliano-hajny-6443
Born in Rome (Italy), living in Tuscany, 54 years old, my 3 favourites are Acqua di Giò Parfum, Terre d'Hermes Parfum anche Chanel Allure Homme Sport.

Active 2h ago
Joined Oct 8, 2026
Arezzo
Powered by