Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
What is this?
Less
More

Memberships

Jewelry IQ with Threefortytwo

619 members • Free

10 contributions to Jewelry IQ with Threefortytwo
Asking for more experienced collectors
As my collection has grown from individual pieces into complete demi-parure and grand parure sets (Juliana, VRBA, Miriam Haskell, Czech, etc), I'm realizing that valuing a collection is much more complicated than pricing a single brooch or pair of earrings. For example, I understand that I can research completed sales on eBay, Worthpoint, LiveAuctioneers, Etsy, Ruby Lane, and dealer websites to estimate a replacement cost or current market value (I wish Whatnot would have this available, or do they??). But those are historical sales, not necessarily what a comparable collection would sell for today or what it would cost to replace if it were lost. What I'm struggling with is understanding how experienced collectors and dealers determine the value of an entire collection or complete set. If I own a rare Juliana demi-parure or grand parure that might be valued around $3,000–$5,000 as a complete set, how is that figure actually determined? Is it based primarily on the last comparable sale, rarity, collector demand, replacement cost, or some combination of those factors? I'm also curious how you account for market fluctuations. For example, if only one complete set is available, scarcity can drive the price up. But if two or three collectors decide to sell comparable sets at the same time, buyers suddenly have options. How do professional appraisers, dealers, and experienced collectors adjust for those changing market conditions? Finally, for those of you who insure significant vintage costume jewelry collections, do you obtain formal appraisals? If so, what type of appraiser do you recommend, how often do you update valuations, and do you insure individual pieces, complete sets, or the collection as a whole? I'd really appreciate hearing from more experienced collectors. I wanted to post here, but I will be reaching out to some large sellers for their opinions, too. Tysm!
Private Jewelry Auction #3 is HOT 🎯
Premium and VIP Skool members have been DMed with the link for tomorrow night. Don't share, and don't lose the link! It's your only way in. It's not too late to get in! Show starts at 8 est. Anyone who signs up by 7PM est tomorrow will get the show link. Go here to upgrade or click your setting/membership: http://skool.com/jewelryiq/plans Jewelry below will all be disappearing, wholesale and under prices, I guarantee it! Lots of kickbacks, free shipping, coupons and $1 starts 😍 I love this event 🐢 Brad/threefortytwo
Private Jewelry Auction #3 is HOT 🎯
0 likes • May 23
@Bradley Johns did Whatnot change their policy on having gateway paywalls?
0 likes • May 24
@Bradley Johns I didn’t see this reply until now. I’ll reply when I have more time to give you actual citations. But, it’s common in business practice everywhere. 🤷🏻‍♀️
Jewelry Trays
Hey guys, I’m curious what your favorite most cost affective jewelry trays have been? I’m not a fan of the velvet ones they catch and hold on to every pet hair within a mile radius.
4 likes • May 15
I go to the thrift store, and I buy any unique pieces that are normally for maybe food or display items that are made of wood or other unique materials. I found some really beautiful handmade wooden items that can be used as display. Anything different and unique to catch a user eye is way better than Buying other flats.
Auction Advice - Take It Or Leave It 🫶🏻
Hope everyone is hitting the mother load this weekend 🤗 Have an awesome day and I'll see people on Whatnot tomorrow night for the auction of the month! Also, our monthly private auction is coming up for premium members! This will be our third! Let's lock in Saturday the 23rd. I had to push this back one week. I will DM a link to all Premium membership folks. Want to sign up? I'd be thrilled to have you. The jewelry is next level, and the prices are dumb, I guarantee it. 💕👍🏻 Go here, easier in a computer: https://www.skool.com/jewelryiq/plans Brad/threefortytwo
Auction Advice - Take It Or Leave It 🫶🏻
1 like • May 15
Really great insight and advice! Tysm
What would you do?
I was going to ask this question in one of the Facebook WhatNot groups but decided not to in case the person I'm referring to is in that group because she would definitely recognize me. So. Last night one of my customers had a payment issue. She couldn't rectify it. She asked me to put aside an item that the payment was rejected for until she was able to get it fixed I said "no problem" Thereafter she started asking me to put away every item that did not sell in an auction. She basically derailed my whole show, she was totally distracting me and I felt like I was being manipulated. I basically lost control of my whole show.. I didn't wanna call her out because I didn't wanna create drama or look like the villain. Another girl that was in the live said that some sellers do this for their regular customers. They hold onto a bunch of items put it in their bin and allow the person to buy them for the auction price. Well this girl was shopping with me for the first time. I don't think any of my regular customers would ask me to do anything like this. Before I knew it there were seven items in the bag. I had spent way too much time on her it was making me flustered and distracting me from what I needed to be doing. My mod was even messaging me asking "what in the hell is this girl doing?" She was acting as if I was her own personal shopping channel and she had a credit card with me. Finally I said "look I will rerun all of this on Monday and you're welcome to bid on it again." I don't think that made her very happy. I have a feeling she's probably just going to ghost me now. Which is fine. I'm totally OK with that. Am I wrong for this? Should I just have set it aside and put it in my bin for her? Generally if I don't sell something I'll rerun it again and sometimes for a higher price and I'll get it. I'm just wondering how I could've handled it better so that it never turned into an issue.
1 like • May 10
There is one particular user that was going in a lot of shows , and buying up a lot but she couldn’t pay immediately she had payment processing issues. One show this buyer repeatedly pre-bid on numerous items but was unable to complete payment processing, effectively holding up the room and limiting opportunities for active buyers who were ready and able to purchase. Situations like this are not a good look from a business or auction management standpoint, especially when it begins interfering with fair and competitive bidding. Strong hosts and moderators should recognize when bid interference is disrupting the flow of a show and consider alternative solutions, such as arranging a separate reseller appointment or bulk purchase opportunity for high-volume buyers, so the live audience still has a fair chance to participate competitively. Good auction rooms thrive on balance, fairness, and efficient management. Needless to say, me, and a few other people in the chat had gotten together and reported the user and the host. I’ve stayed off Whatnot for several weeks now and I just can’t go back until a lot of people just improve their business acumen or until I find rooms that the seller doesn’t favorite these types of buyers.
1 like • May 10
@Carla Kohler I completely understand being a newer seller, and situations like this are definitely learning experiences. One thing I’ve learned from nursing and teaching students is that boundaries and process matter for everyone involved. For example, when teaching a new nurse to start an IV, if after a couple of unsuccessful attempts it’s clearly not working, you stop and bring in someone more experienced so the patient isn’t unnecessarily stressed or traumatized. I think auction rooms are similar in a way — if repeated payment failures or bidding issues are disrupting the flow of the show, at some point the host has to step in to protect the experience for the rest of the buyers who are ready and able to participate fairly. It’s not about excluding anyone; it’s about maintaining a professional, balanced, and comfortable environment for the entire room. Sometimes a separate reseller arrangement or private purchase opportunity may be the better option for high-volume buyers so the live audience still has a fair chance to bid competitively. Just my thoughts
1-10 of 10
Elizabeth Kaley
2
1point to level up
@elizabeth-kaley-7345
Nurse Scientist & Vintage Jewelry Hoarding for 40+ yrs., worked the jewelry counter FIDM graduate 🧑‍🎓 College Professor, Ph.D 👩‍⚕️

Active 2h ago
Joined Apr 13, 2026
INTJ
Sierra Madre, California
Powered by