There are corners of Victorian London that seem almost designed to conceal dreadful things.
Narrow passages where daylight hesitates, respectable shopfronts masking private miseries, and where violence, when it erupted, did so with shocking intimacy. Artillery Passage was one such place.
In the spring of 1868, eighteen-year-old Alexander Arthur Mackay worked as a waiter and general servant for George Grossmith (no, not that one…), proprietor of a modest chop house at No. 11. By all appearances it was an ordinary establishment, the sort of place swallowed by the daily bustle of the City. Yet behind its kitchen door unfolded a tragedy that would carry Mackay to an unwanted distinction: he would become the first man executed within the walls of Newgate Prison after public hangings were abolished.
The catastrophe began on the morning of Friday the 8th May. With George Grossmith absent, Mackay quarrelled with his employer’s wife, Emma, a woman of forty-five. Whatever sparked the disagreement soon gave way to uncontrollable brutality. The kitchen ceased to resemble any place where food ought to be prepared, becoming instead the sort of establishment that would have had an Environmental Health Officer reaching for the paperwork, before realising this particular inspection required rather more policemen than clipboards.
Emma clung on for nine days.
Remarkably, she recovered consciousness long enough to identify her attacker and give a statement to the police before finally succumbing to the appalling injuries inflicted upon her.
Mackay, meanwhile, vanished.
For several weeks, he succeeded in slipping through the widening net, adopting the name George Jackson and travelling to Maidstone, where fate intervened in the most Victorian of fashions.
Henry Ratcliff, a prison warder blessed with an exceptional memory for faces, recognised the resemblance between the man calling himself Jackson and an illustration of the fugitive Mackay.
On the 28th of June, he was questioned, identified, and escorted back to London, where Newgate Prison awaited him.
His trial opened at the Old Bailey on the 17th of August before Mr Justice Lush. Mackay was represented by two defence counsel, yet the evidence proved overwhelming.
Neighbours recalled hearing violent disturbances around half past nine that morning. One heard Emma’s desperate cry: “Oh don’t.” Another witnessed the young servant fleeing, stained with blood. Surgeon John Jackson described the scene he encountered and the terrible injuries from which Emma would never recover.
The jury found Mackay guilty, though they appealed for mercy because of his youth. He had been only eighteen when the murder was committed, celebrating his nineteenth birthday while awaiting execution. Compassion, however, found little purchase with the Home Secretary, Earl Cranbrook, who declined to interfere. The sentence would be carried out on Tuesday the 8th of September 1868.
By then, the age of the public spectacle had officially ended. No crowds would gather outside Newgate’s walls to witness justice enacted. The gallows had merely retreated from public view. (Damn shame…)
The scaffold stood in a corner of the enclosed chapel yard, stark and functional: twin upright beams supporting a crosspiece from which hung an iron chain. Beneath lay the modest drop, screened from view by plain sheeting. It was, in fact, the very apparatus that had served only months earlier for Michael Barrett’s public execution—a grim relic of an era already passing into history.
Shortly before nine o’clock, Mackay emerged from the condemned cell, accompanied by the prison chaplain, the Reverend Mr Jones. The Governor, the prison surgeon, sheriffs, officials and a carefully selected gathering of journalists watched in solemn silence. Unlike earlier executions, no warders stood beside the prisoner upon the scaffold. Only Mackay, the chaplain and the executioner, William Calcraft, occupied the fatal platform.
As prayers concluded, Mackay spoke his final words
“Oh Lord God have mercy upon me.”
Calcraft completed his preparations, stepped clear, and released the bolt. The drop measured barely a foot or so by modern standards, and death came not by a swift breaking of the neck but by slow strangulation. Contemporary reports recorded several convulsive struggles lasting around two minutes before all movement ceased.
Outside the prison, unseen by the public, the black flag climbed above Newgate’s walls. At nearby St Sepulchre’s Church, the great bell tolled, announcing that the law had taken another life.
An hour later, the body was removed for the formal inquest. Curiously, observers remarked upon the unusual serenity of Mackay’s face. One warder commented that such a peaceful expression was rarely seen after execution.
That afternoon Deputy Coroner W. H. Payne convened the statutory inquest with a jury of twenty-one City of London jurors. The proceedings were necessarily brief. The Governor identified the deceased and produced the death warrant; the prison surgeon confirmed that the cause of death was judicial hanging. The verdict could scarcely have been otherwise.
Mackay was buried anonymously within the prison precincts, his grave left without monument or inscription. Yet anonymity proved short-lived.
Within days, the entrepreneurial machinery of Victorian curiosity had transformed him into another morbid attraction. A wax likeness appeared in Madame Tussaud’s Chamber of Horrors, where visitors could gaze upon the latest addition to London’s gallery of infamous dead—a final irony for a young man whose desperate attempt to disappear had ended by ensuring he would be remembered.