12d (edited) • Questions❓
Daily SAT Question 9/18
Answer to yesterday's was -25.
DIFFICULTY: HARD
On Atlantic shores, dogwhelks living where predatory crabs are abundant generally have thicker shells than dogwhelks living where crabs are scarce. Dogwhelks can thicken newly formed shell material after detecting chemical cues from crabs, so some shell variation is environmentally induced. In one study, however, researchers collected unhatched egg capsules from crab-rich and crab-poor shores and raised the hatchlings under identical, cue-free laboratory conditions. Hatchlings whose mothers came from crab-rich shores still developed thicker shells. The researchers interpreted this persistent difference as evidence that shell thickness primarily reflects inherited genetic differences between the populations rather than effects of parental environments carried into offspring.
Which finding, if true, would most directly challenge the researchers’ interpretation?
A genomic comparison finds that snails from crab-rich and crab-poor shores differ in the frequency of several variants associated with shell formation.
Snails from both shore types increase shell thickness by the same proportion when exposed to crab cues after hatching.
In field trials, thicker-shelled snails survive crab attacks more often, whereas thinner-shelled snails grow faster where crabs are scarce.
After two generations bred separately by origin in the same cue-free conditions, the shell-thickness difference disappears, while first-generation thickness tracks nutrient levels in the original egg capsules.
31 votes
5
8 comments
John Hoegerl
8
Daily SAT Question 9/18
Gamify SAT
skool.com/gamifysat
Helping Gamers Master the SAT.
Leaderboard (30-day)
Powered by