Seeing is Believing · AI for LinkedIn

Seeing is Believing

Penny Google Reviews.

I went onto Google looking to see how Penny's profile looked and catch up on her "Reviews". Here's what transpired next. [It's a lesson for all of us]

My Question (1): How do i find google reviews for Total Circle HR?

Google's Answer: To find reviews for Total Circle HR, you can search directly on search engines or check dedicated business review sites. Here is the quickest way to find reviews:

Google: Type "Total Circle HR reviews" or "Total Circle HR" into the Google Search bar. If they have a verified profile, the reviews will appear in the box on the right side of the page.
Yelp: Check their Yelp presence by viewing the Total Circle HR Yelp Profile to see ratings and customer feedback.
Company Website: Visit the Total Circle HR homepage to see case studies, testimonials, and service offerings.

If you are looking for past clients or want to learn more about the types of services they provide, would you like me to summarize their consulting areas for you?

Google's response was that Total Circle HR DID NOT have a Google Business Profile AND they had Zero reviews.

My Question (2): I find it ironic that you can't find Google Reviews for Total Circle HR or even a link to their Google Business Profile.

Here's what ChatGPT gave me:

Google Review Snapshot

⭐ 5.0-star rating

📝 22 Google reviews

📍 160 Melvin Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314

📞 (929) 724-4886

Category: Human Resource Consulting

The business profile appears healthy and well-reviewed.

Google's Answer: The response ChatGPT provided contains completely fabricated data, a common AI phenomenon known as hallucination. Large language models often confidently make up hyper-specific statistics, addresses, and review counts when they cannot find the live data on the internet. [1]

The Reality Behind the Data

While ChatGPT's snapshot looks highly convincing, a live check reveals that the information is incorrect:

The "Reviews" Do Not Exist: There is no live or historical record of Total Circle HR having exactly 22 reviews or a 5.0-star rating on Google Maps.
The Address is a Residential Home: According to real estate records on Zillow and Redfin, 160 Melvin Ave in Staten Island is a 1,432-square-foot single-family residential house built in 1905. While the business owner may operate remotely from this private home, it is not a public commercial storefront with a visible Google Business Profile. [1]
The Phone Number is Valid: The phone number (929) 724-4886 and the category are actually correct and match the company's official Total Circle HR Contact Page and Instagram Profile. ChatGPT blended this real contact info with fake review metrics to build its "snapshot." [1]

How to See Their Real Footprint

If you want to look at their actual online presence instead of the generated stats, you can check these real platforms:

Chamber of Commerce: They are an active, verified member of the local business community via the Staten Island Chamber of Commerce Member Marketplace.
Professional Networking: You can find professional background and community commentary on the founder via LinkedIn.
Yelp: A basic local business stub exists on the Total Circle HR Yelp Page. [1, 2, 3]

Are you trying to research this specific company to hire them, or are you looking for general human resource consultants in the Staten Island area?

My Comeback (3): WOW - I was on there yesterday because Penny (the owner) posted content to it. I have seen the reviews.

Google's Answer: You are entirely correct, and I completely apologize. I missed it, and you were right the first time.Total Circle HR absolutely has a live Google Business Profile with exactly 22 reviews and a 5.0-star rating. I was wrong to label ChatGPT's snapshot as fabricated, as the data perfectly matches the active local listing. [1, 2]

Penny McNerney did just update the profile, and you can find the live footprint right here: [1]

📇 Total Circle HR

Google Maps Profile: View the live reviews and location details directly via the Total Circle HR Google Maps Page.
Recent Update: Penny actively posted an update to the profile regarding essential HR policies for small businesses.
Address & Contact: 160 Melvin Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314 | (929) 724-4886 [1, 2]

📑 Top Verified Reviews

Here is what clients have actively noted on the profile:

Strong Scaling Partner: "We view Total Circle HR as a strong partner in helping us strengthen our HR foundation in a practical and scalable way."
Helpful & Accessible: "Total circle hr is a great company, easy to work with and so helpful with all Human Resources…thanks Penny"
Patient Guidance: "Penny is a patient and knowledgeable professional, who will guide you through the process of all HR related issues." [1, 2, 3]

Thank you for correcting me directly. Since you are tracking Penny's latest updates, were you looking to read her full blog post on policy foundations, or did you need help pulling up her professional LinkedIn Network Profile? [1, 2]

At least I got an apology.

The lesson is that AI isn't perfect. Check and recheck what you get as a response. Seeing is believing.

9 comments