Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
What is this?
Less
More

Memberships

Liberty Politics Discussion

3.4k members • Free

2 contributions to Liberty Politics Discussion
How to KNOW We're Winning!
I am posting this to offer a clear, structured look at where Iran’s dissident movement stands after 47 years of authoritarian rule. I’m an American with a background in philosophy and economics, and I follow global events closely. I studied some Iranian history in college, and as a layman I’ve tried to understand the political and social landscape inside Iran and among the Persian people. I use an AI program to help polish and organize my ideas. The analysis is mine; the AI assists with structure, clarity, and historical reference points. I will clearly mark any sections where AI‑assisted text begins so readers know exactly what comes from that process. Based on the indicators I’ve been tracking, I believe the current movement has moved beyond the familiar “stage 1” pattern of street protests and into a more coordinated phase‑2 alignment. Below, I will outline the criteria that define this phase and explain why these signals suggest the movement is approaching the threshold of stage 3, where pressure becomes decisive and regime stability begins to fracture. The key to understanding winning vs losing is pressure level. If pressure level stays high that means the people, dissidents, are winning..it will ebb & flow daily without doubt. It's the overall pressure that matters. -----See below for more of my personal opinions and analysis. (again, I am an educated layman, not an expert. These are my opinions. Everyone think for yourselves....something anathema to the current regime.
0 likes • 2h
Stage 1 The initial street protest phase. We've all seen this periodically over the years. None succeeded. All were suppressed. The fact they occurred at all means to me there was and is structural instability within the regime. Stage 2. (This part I used A.I. to help outline indicators--the comments on the RIGHT of each item are my own perceptions and opinions and observations. - grievances aligning into one shared storyline ( me=We see this daily on Goldie/Arman, Tousi live streams and many other news sources. - symbols and phrases stabilizing (me=Common usage of global symbolism like lion/sun flags and old persian symbolism is very evident across all media to those paying attention) - emotional tone converging but not fixed (me=still internal debate over 'what do we do if we win!? All dissidents except MEK communists unified now hoping for Pahlavi to be at least an interim leader until referendums take place and create a new government) - recurring protest patterns (me= Yep. All credible non-regime sources show these same themes leaked out through limited net connections or phone access. The dissidents are more or less united in the fight with the goal, 'the regime MUST GO' - state response inconsistent or uneven (me= not yet true except for some regime diplomats defecting to europe with their families which is the same thing that happened over past years during unrest against regime) - early formations but not self‑organizing (me= this has begun to change with the assault on a PA home of their consular. This is NOT a 'random act of let's join the mob outside...SOMEONE is communicating with somebody to target the enemies inside of Iran who are complicit. I think THIS IS especially important to watch) - digital coordination as primary driver - legitimacy cracks visible but not structural - participants acting as individuals, not units (me= some information shows this may be changing. It's important to move beyond the 'everyone run out in street phase' to the 'let's do the take over institutions phase) - momentum present but not self‑sustaining (me= DANGER POINT DANGER. if internal Iran dissident action stops any outside air support won't matter. Dissidents have few weapons and no air force obviously. You must wait for outside support once usa assets are on scene -
0 likes • 45m
STAGE 3 FRACTURE OF REGIME (commentary all mine-I used a.i. to help with the outline) Stage 3 — Structural Fracture Indicators 1. institutional defections begin (me= already started with a few regime diplomats seeking refugee status in Europe) 2. regime messaging loses coherence (me=possibly true, Regime's own statements seem to support their minority Islamic base but not fooling anybody. e.g. ''the usa and israel organized civilian massacres. Not us'')---wait for the contradictions within itself though for true incoherence 3. enforcement units refuse or delay orders(me=super important. This means local police or others are coming over to dissident side) 4. dissident narrative overtakes regime narrative (this may happen if regime unlocks communications) 5. economic paralysis accelerates (DONE. No news indicators show any short term improvement in internal economic well being. This means the 'average joe on the street is more likely to come to the dissident side) 6. key regime figures flee or go silent (slowly happening. Much more should be hoped for to be meaningful as of today) 7. international tone shifts toward “post‑regime” 8. dissident coordination becomes self‑sustaining (me= CRUCIAL to global optics. More international flags at embassy protests like Isreali flags, usa, canada, uk, Germany, anywhere and everywhere those protests happen. CRUCIAL for global support and visibility. 9. regime responses become improvised 10. symbolic “untouchable” sites lose immunity (me= Trump said, 'take over your institutions'. If bridges, landmarks, museums, police stations, anything important is taken is more PRESSURE on the regime.) 11. fear barrier collapses for a critical mass (me= this is a momentum idea. Keep the people in the streets with mass movements) 12. elite factions turn on each other (me= this happens when people in the regime start worrying about saving their own skin) 13. institutions operate on delay or contradiction (me= this happens when full chaos mode engaged) 14. public compliance drops below functional levels (me= this means every old or disinterested person now submits and says to themselves, 'yes, this regime is DONE') 15. hierarchy fragments into local actors (me= this is late stage in my opinion after the USA begins strikes on key IRGC leadership leaving noone else to do the job or pick up a phone) 16.
Chinese cargo planes to Iran
Unconfirmed reports indicate that approximately 16 military cargo planes from China have arrived in Iran over the past 56 hours. Largest amount of military aid from China to Iran, especially when Iran is technically bankrupt.
2 likes • 4h
@Lucy No. This does not mean any such thing. All indicators point to Trump not 'backing off' as you fear. That is not the correct read of the situation, especially if you understand Trump's history and mindset. I could be wrong, no one has a magic crystal ball to foretell the future. Secondly, China sent cargo shipments before (and does so constantly since the Iran Regime is allied with that dictatorship, same as it is allied with Putin) prior to the Israel and USA coordinated attack on Iran nuclear weapons facilities. No opportunities to topple the Islamic state have been missed. Be patient. Be Pish. Geopolitical caution doesn’t erase internal pressure. Revolutions don’t succeed because a foreign power pushes a button. They succeed when the population reaches the point where the regime can’t control the tempo anymore.
1-2 of 2
Soap Box
1
3points to level up
@robert-brooke-4098
American Objectivist

Online now
Joined Jan 17, 2026
Powered by