@Jack Pinard Great post. Based on what you've shared, I wouldn't put too much weight on the rental analyzer alone. After more than years in real estate investing, development, and value add projects, I've seen many properties appear underwhelming on paper when analyzed strictly as rentals, yet turn out to be exceptional investments because of their underlying development potential. The fact that this property includes a separate buildable lot immediately changes the conversation. In my experience, the highest-value component of a deal is often the piece that isn't captured by standard rental metrics. The key questions become: What can be built? What does the zoning allow? What are the infrastructure and permitting considerations? And what is the highest and best use of that lot? Without seeing all the details, my initial thought is that the property's true value may lie more in its future development potential than in its current rental performance. I'd love to hear more about the lot size, zoning, frontage, utilities, and any conversations you've had with the town. Feel free to reply here or send me a message, I'd be happy to share my perspective and help you evaluate the opportunities that may not be showing up in the analyzer.