Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
What is this?
Less
More

Memberships

Brotherhood Of Scent

8.7k members • Free

189 contributions to Brotherhood Of Scent
Had to get the shelf!
Thanks to @Robert Sheard I followed suit and got this great shelf for my arsenal- 😊 it now sits proudly among my watches and jewelry box.
Had to get the shelf!
3 likes • 5h
Excellent. Love to see it.
Had to buy some shelves
My little collection is already growing so quickly. I blame all of you! 🤣 I can see that these two little units will be full shortly and then I'll have to improvise. There is no organizational scheme here (yet) other than size and shapes of the bottles.
Had to buy some shelves
1 like • 1d
@Stephen DeMent I'm happy with the way they've worked out.
1 like • 22h
@Nestor Lopez Thanks, Nestor!
A Note Mystery... I Need Help
A question for the experienced brothers: Several weeks ago I tried Givenchy Gentleman Society Reserve PrivƩe because everyone says it's the top of the Givenchy line. I really disliked it, but I couldn't figure out why. Today I tried a sample of MFK's Grand Soir. And I really dislike it, too, in pretty much the same way as Reserve PrivƩe. I'm wondering if it's the amber note I don't like? But I don't really know what amber smells like so I can't be sure. Are there other popular designer fragrances that are strong amber scents so I can try to figure out what it is I don't like? I would love to get a kit from somewhere to let me experience scents in isolation to pin down my likes and dislikes.
2 likes • 1d
Thanks, Paul. I admit I just don't know enough to know whether it's a note issue or a quality issue. While I continue to learn, I'll have to keep doing lots of side-by-side tests to identify what I like versus what I dislike. If nothing else, it's cured me of ever blind buying anything.
1 like • 1d
@Lon Chaneyfield Thanks, Lon. Yes, it's confusing because several other amber-based fragrances are ones I really enjoy. More testing to do.
Mail call!!
Picked up a bunch of decants from decantx! All the big decants except for the gold I bought so I can decant my favorite scents. The gold one is Stronger with you freeze 🄶 it’s a shame they discontinued it because it’s soo good and fresh. I picked up the new YSL iced, azzaro absolute, Valentino purple, and Armani SWY powerfully. I’ll be using them over the next couple days as SOTD/maybe review more my thoughts then a full breakdown.
Mail call!!
5 likes • 3d
I've been over-buying decants recently. I need to slow down. Rookie question about DecantX, though. They don't label the outside of their travel sprays. How do you remember which is which, or do you open it to check the bottle each time? I'm too old to trust my memory anymore.
4 likes • 3d
@Dave Anderson That may already be in my cart, but I could never confirm that. 🤣
Gentleman I’m back
Tried the Givenchy GS line this week, here’s my rankings. (do not hold back on comments!) šŸ˜• 4th place: OG 🪵🌸 - nothing special, pretty good but missing oomph. šŸ„‰ 3rd place: AmbrĆ©e šŸš¬šŸŒ¶ļøšŸ¦- the faint sweetness is nice but doesn’t really do it… reminds me of SB Extreme. 🄈 2nd place: Sport šŸ‹šŸŖ» - this one grew on me, at first it smelled grassy but took another sniff and it works. šŸ† 1st place: ExtrĆŖmeā˜•ļøšŸµšŸƒ - seduced my snout… The iris, coffee and mint combo in this is magnifique! Out of the whole line this is the one to reach for.
Gentleman I’m back
2 likes • 3d
I haven't tried the Sport yet, but I've tried everything else in the line, I think, and still can't decide. For me, it comes down to the OG, even with its less-than-stellar performance, and Extreme. I need to do some more side-by-side testing.
1-10 of 189
Robert Sheard
7
4,908points to level up
@robert-sheard-5918
I'm a semi-retired writer, teacher, speech and debate coach. I am currently the Director of the BookTube Prize and hope to write more books.

Active 5h ago
Joined Dec 11, 2025
INTJ
Durham, North Carolina, USA
Powered by