Its unlikely there's anything wrong with the EQ plugin, so I agree with Chris, mainly his comment about hearing loss. It is possible that if you were to turn up your monitors whilst doing the same manipulation you might start to hear some variation. One way to make that experiment less painful would be to cut all the frequencies below say 1Khz first. However, what you'll hear all depends on your hearing (assuming the source has reasonable high frequency content and that your monitors or headphones can reproduce them - most can). Another way to judge what's happening would be to place another plugin after the EQ that gives a visual indication of the frequency content. Maybe your DAW features such a plugin. You should see the change in high frequency content when 'wiggling' the EQ band, and that would first of all confirm that the HF content exists, secondly that the EQ is affecting it, and thirdly that for one reason or another you are not hearing that variation. Anyway, it seems that you've just discovered one of the complications in being totally objective when listening to music, mixing and mastering. It doesn't mean you can't get past it (my hearing isn't great) but it adds a little more fun to it all 😃.