Tracking Local SEO Performance: A Friendly Guide for Agencies and Small Businesses

If you want your business to pop up when locals search for what you offer, you need more than just a website—you need to keep tabs on how you’re doing in local search. The good news? Tracking your local SEO performance isn’t rocket science, especially with the right approach and tools.

Let’s break down the essentials, share some practical tips, and make the whole process a lot less intimidating.

Why Track Local SEO Metrics?

Think of local SEO metrics as your business’s health check. They tell you how visible you are to nearby customers, where you shine, and where you might want to step up your game. By keeping an eye on these signals, you can:

Spot which locations are bringing in the most traffic and sales.
See how you stack up against the competition.
Fine-tune your marketing spend for better results.
Understand what your customers love—and what needs work.
Shape your content and advertising to match what locals are actually searching for.

Ignoring these signals is a bit like driving with your eyes closed. So, let’s see which metrics matter most.

Key Local SEO Metrics to Watch

Local Search Rankings: Where you show up in Google Maps and search results for your target keywords. The higher, the better—since most people rarely scroll past the top few results.
Google Business Profile (GBP) Insights: Your GBP (formerly Google My Business) is a goldmine of data. Track how often your listing pops up, what actions people take (calls, website visits, directions), and which search terms bring them in.
Online Reviews and Ratings: Both the number and quality of reviews matter. Glowing feedback not only draws in more customers but also helps you climb the ranks. Don’t forget to keep tabs on what people are saying and how you’re responding.
Local Citations: These are mentions of your business on directories, social media, and other sites. Consistency is key—make sure your name, address, and phone number are the same everywhere.
Competitor Metrics: Keep an eye on your rivals. How many reviews do they have? How do they respond to customers? Where do they rank for important keywords? This can reveal opportunities for you to stand out.
Website Traffic from Local Search: Use analytics to see how many visitors find you through local searches, and what percentage of them take action (like filling out a contact form or making a purchase).
Phone Calls: Call tracking tools can show you which SEO efforts are driving real-world inquiries.
Page Load Times: Slow sites lose visitors. Speed things up to keep people engaged and boost your conversion rates.

Tools to Make Tracking a Breeze

You don’t have to juggle spreadsheets or guess what’s working. These tools can do the heavy lifting:

Google Analytics: Breaks down website traffic by location, shows which pages attract local visitors, and tracks conversions.
Google Search Console: Reveals which search queries bring people to your site, your rankings, and any issues that might be holding you back.
Semrush Local: This all-in-one platform tracks your Google Maps rankings, analyzes reviews, monitors competitors, and keeps your business info consistent across directories. It even creates handy heatmaps to show where you’re winning and where you could improve.

How Semrush Local Helps You Shine

Map Rank Tracker: Visualizes your Google Maps performance for target keywords across your area, so you know exactly where you’re visible.
Review Analytics: Benchmarks your reviews and ratings against competitors, helping you understand customer sentiment and spot areas for improvement.
Competitors Review Report: Lets you compare your reviews, response rates, and ratings with local rivals, so you can find ways to leap ahead.
Listing Management: Keeps your business details consistent across directories, making it easier for customers to find you and for search engines to trust your info.

Tips for Agencies and Small Businesses

Set up regular reporting so you’re always up to date.
Use insights from reviews and competitor analysis to guide your service improvements.
Focus on the locations and keywords that deliver the best results.
Don’t just collect data—act on it. Test, tweak, and repeat for ongoing growth.

Tracking your local SEO doesn’t have to be a chore. With the right tools and a clear focus on the metrics that matter, you can boost your visibility, attract more local customers, and keep your business growing—all without breaking a sweat.

1 comment

SEO Success Academy

skool.com/seo-success-academy

Welcome to SEO Success Academy – the ultimate destination for business owners, digital marketers and agencies to master the art and science of SEO.

Leaderboard (30-day)