These three QV 5/- are in the same auction, one under the other.
The first one has two Liverpool cancels (which suits my preference for Liverpool cancels), and is listed as "extra fine". The second, with a nice Jersey cancel is listed a step down as "fine-very fine". The third one has a heavy-ish registered cancel and some perf issues, yet is also listed as "extra fine", it also has a defect.
The first one has full, complete perfs, but a slightly greasy cancellation, the second has a few blunt perfs but a clean almost face-free cancellation, the third has some blunt perfs and a defect.
Which one has the best appeal for you and why?