Yes, you can create and offer a different show using the same props. I have done it, you can too. I have two retirement centers that hires me every month for a show.
They are pleased with every show.
Here is an example. I own a pizza box, one where the pizza slides back and forth and eventually vanished. I use that same box using a cut down 45 record. My routine is all about records, songs from the past. They love remembering those old songs as I them to share their favorites.
The pages in my coloring book change as I tell The story about having a dream.