Posterior hip precautions after THA — are we doing this for nothing?
I've been thinking about this for a while. We routinely give posterior precautions after posterior approach THA, but the evidence that they actually reduce dislocation risk is pretty thin. Deckard et al. published a series of 580 hips using a monoblock dual mobility construct via mini-posterior approach where they deliberately abandoned traditional posterior precautions. Cup positioning was based on anatomic landmarks rather than radiographic targets. The dislocation rate was 0.2% — a single case, in a patient with pre-existing spinal cord injury and Charcot arthropathy. That aligns well with Clair et al.'s systematic review comparing dislocation rates by approach with dual mobility. Regardless of approach, 80 to 100 percent of studies reported zero postoperative dislocations. And the older but heavily cited review by Petrie and Sassoon noted that restrictive postoperative precautions simply don't influence dislocation rates — whereas lumbosacral pathology, BMI over 30, and surgeon experience do. My read: precautions probably serve no function when you're using dual mobility, and they're unnecessarily limiting early rehabilitation. What's your experience? Have you moved away from them, or are you still giving standard precautions?