Why 'mind if I send the file over' outperforms every pitch I've tried

Been testing a new opener on a cold email campaign for the past 5 days and wanted to share the numbers + why I think it's working, mostly because a few people here have asked what's been working lately.

1800 sent, 108 replies (6%), 48 of those positive (44% of replies). Small sample, still early, could level off, but wanted to share while it's fresh instead of waiting for a "perfect" case study.

The email itself is stupidly simple: "{FIRST_NAME}, I put together a list of 60 {IDEAL_CUSTOMER} that share the exact same characteristics as the highest-paying accounts in your niche and are in need of {COMPANY_SERVICE}. Mind if I send the file over? Aurel" That's it. No pitch, no "I help companies like yours", no case study in the first line.

What I think is actually doing the work here isn't the copy, it's the ask. "Mind if I send the file over" is about the smallest yes you can ask for. You're not asking for a call, you're not asking for their time, you're asking permission to send something free. Almost nobody says no to that, and once they say yes once, the second ask (the real one) gets a lot easier. Also no link in this first email, which I think matters more than people give it credit for. Every link you add in email 1 is a reason for a filter to flag you before a human even sees it.

Not claiming this is some breakthrough, people have been doing list-based hooks forever. Just sharing because the reply quality has been noticeably higher than my usual openers, and figured some of you testing new copy might want a data point. Happy to answer questions if anyone's running something similar.

3 comments

Why 'mind if I send the file over' outperforms every pitch I've tried