3d • General discussion
The Owner Who Demands to See "Everything": How Far Do Your Records Have to Go?
SCENARIO
An owner in your Cambridge condominium - recently frustrated over a fee increase - sends the board a sweeping demand: he wants to inspect "all association records," including full financials, every board meeting's minutes, all vendor contracts, the bank statements, and the board's email correspondence about a recent dispute involving his own late fees. He cites his rights as a unit owner and sets a seven-day deadline, hinting at legal action if the board doesn't comply.
Two trustees want to stonewall him - "he's just fishing, and it's none of his business." One wants to hand over literally everything to avoid a fight. The treasurer is worried: some of those records mention other owners' delinquencies by name.
DISCUSSION QUESTION
What is this owner actually entitled to see, and what should the board be careful about handing over? Where would you look to find the rule?
RECOMMENDED APPROACH
1. Start from the presumption of transparency, not secrecy. In Massachusetts, condominium owners generally have a right to access association records - financials, budgets, minutes, and similar governance documents. Stonewalling a legitimate request is usually the wrong instinct and can itself trigger the legal fight the board is trying to avoid. Your governing documents and Chapter 183A frame these rights; check them first.
2. "Entitled to records" is not "entitled to everything, however he wants it." The right of access typically applies to official association records and can come with reasonable conditions - advance notice, reasonable times, sometimes reasonable copying costs. A seven-day ultimatum doesn't override a reasonable, good-faith process.
3. Protect other owners' private information. Records that identify other owners' delinquencies, health information, or similar sensitive details deserve care - redaction or handling on advice of counsel - so satisfying one owner's request doesn't breach others' privacy.
4. "The board's private emails" is a genuinely gray area - get counsel. Whether informal trustee email correspondence is an "association record" subject to inspection isn't always clear-cut. Run it past your attorney rather than answering on instinct under a deadline.
5. Respond in writing, professionally, and on your timeline - not his. Acknowledge the request, state what you'll provide and the reasonable process, note any items you're reviewing with counsel, and document that you responded in good faith.
The instinct to fight and the instinct to surrender are both wrong. The right move is a calm, documented, good-faith response that honors real access rights while protecting other owners and getting legal advice on the uncertain parts.
OPTIONAL RESOURCE
"Handling an Owner Records Request in Massachusetts" - a step-by-step response flow with a redaction and 'check-with-counsel' checklist.
WHY THIS MATTERS
Records requests are increasingly common - often from an already-upset owner - and boards routinely mishandle them by stonewalling (liability) or over-sharing (privacy breach). Teaching transparency-with-guardrails is practical and distinctly Massachusetts.
0
0 comments
The Owner Who Demands to See "Everything": How Far Do Your Records Have to Go?
powered by
skool.com/condoops-hoa-training-hub-6363
Free training and community for Massachusetts condo and HOA trustees.Learn what the job really involves, protect your board, and run a better building
Suggested communities
Powered by