For me its very clear and it does the job of all the things we have been talking about for several months on skool. Where it falls down, OR is going to fall down, I think is that it is very rich and busy - in a clearly AI-generated way. It doesnt have the obvious and most horrible elements like lots of swooshes, underlines and the now disgusting paintbrush-style fonts, but it still has a strong AI-gen vibe for me. I feel like the backlash on this stuff has started and is spreading through different industries - so I would just be looking at it and thinking how can i improve it and future-proof against that. Don't get me wrong - I can see how, why you have made it like this and I think its great. Mine has some of the same elements. So what I am saying applies to me too. Suggestions would be 1) take away some of the additional little messages everywhere (in the background, on the book - im surprised there isnt one on the cup) 2) reduce some of the texture like the leaves 3) maybe take away the warm lights or candles since there is already a window providing light.... Hope that's helpful. The other thing would just be too look around at other groups and styles and you will likely find the same elements and just try to stand out from them. You will find a lot that are worse, and much fewer that are better :)