Hi Mike! First of all, welcome to the world of trading! Please do not hesitate to make use of the resources provided to you in this Skool community! To answer your question, based on the course material, noāyou would not take that Superman entry just because the 5-minute setup formed if the overall Superman criteria were never satisfied from the higher-timeframe plan. The key sequence is: 1. Price must first return to your 1-hour plan area (your supply or demand zone). 2. Then you wait for the required 5-minute confirmation (market shift/change of structure, engulfing pattern, etc., depending on whether you're trading with or against trend). 3. Only after that do you look for the 5-minute Superman entry. The 5-minute chart is there to refine the entryānot replace the 1-hour plan. One of Kyle's examples is almost identical to what you're describing: - Price came into the plan area. - The 5-minute confirmation formed. - But price never returned to the newly created 5-minute demand before reaching the plan target. - Result: there was no valid Superman entry, even though the overall move still worked and the Jedi entry would have been a winner. He also emphasizes that if the setup doesn't meet the criteria, you simply let it go: If you don't get filled or the criteria aren't met, don't chase itāyou just missed that Superman move. That's OK. So for your specific question: - If the 1-hour plan area was never actually reached, then no Superman trade. - If the 1-hour plan area was reached, but only the 5-minute confirmation occurred, then yes, provided the rest of the Superman rules are met. - A 5-minute return by itself is not enough. The 5-minute chart is only used after the higher-timeframe plan has already qualified the setup. A good rule of thumb is: 1-hour chart = "Where am I allowed to trade?" 5-minute chart = "How do I enter that trade?" The 5-minute setup should always be nested inside the higher-timeframe plan.