At what point do you decide to sue for damages after a tenant moves out? Is there a dollar amount that anyone uses? I had a tenant that moved in a sibling about 6 months ago. Long story short, they went from being a good, quiet, tenant who pays on time...to a nightmare for the whole building. Thankfully they agreed to end the lease early and moved out, rather than be evicted. Now I am looking at $5000+ in damages and cleaning fees. Thats not counting the appliances that will have to be replaced. I won't recoup this loss overnight! Is this something I should consider for small claims?