This was a good read. While I can’t say I experienced 12 step quite the same way I can definitely agree with the thinking. I have my own reasons for thinking it’s a cult. I think the only reason I don’t agree with all your points is because my personal experiences were different and I was mostly in NA and only used NA literature. That being said, my primary thought is still the same - the fellowship creates dependency, it manipulates you into acts of service (to relieve the guilt it creates and the guilt you came with that it keeps enforcing), it takes away autonomy, and leaves you with the narrative that your best thinking was and is shit. They underwhelming stress the importance of outside and professional help. I often felt like it’s mention more or less as a disclaimer to cover their asses as a corporation. In addition by doing this they stunt the growth of the persons recovering. There are many sick people celebrating clean time; the idea that because of their clean time their sharing or sponsoring carries weight is gross. My spouse still attends meetings. I stopped going to support him because we have children now and I will not bring them into meetings. They have no business being there. And I do not trust who is there. It concerns me this is where my spouse gets support. Principals before personalities means ignore predators and predatory behavior in a room because they have a right to be there. Also gross. I could go on.