Happy Wednesday, team! Big news yesterday: builder confidence fell to 25, the lowest since April 2012. 46% of builders cut prices this month, the average cut was 6%, and 68% offered deals like paying to lower the buyer's rate (National Association of Home Builders). Sellers are negotiating. So let's do the math on what asking for a deal is actually worth. EXAMPLE - not a real listing, not a loan offer - Duplex price: $400,000 - FHA loan, 3.5% down: $14,000 - Loan: $392,755 (includes FHA's 1.75% upfront mortgage insurance) - Rate: 7.05% (Mortgage News Daily 30-year FHA average, Nov 17) - Principal and interest: $2,626 - Property taxes ($4,800 a year): $400 - Insurance ($2,400 a year): $200 - FHA mortgage insurance (0.55% a year): $177 - Full monthly payment: $3,403 - Rent from the other unit: $1,750, minus 5% for empty months, is $1,662 - Your net housing cost: about $1,741 a month Now two ways to ask for a deal: 1. Ask for 6% off the price (the builders' average cut): at $376,000, with the same taxes and insurance, the full payment drops to about $3,235, about $168 a month less. Your net cost is about $1,572. 2. Ask the seller to pay to lower your rate 1 point, to 6.05%: the full payment drops to about $3,144, about $259 a month less. Your net cost is about $1,482. The rate cut wins on the monthly payment, if it lasts all 30 years. Realtor.com found new-home buyers started at an average 5.01% rate from July to September, but some of those were temporary rate cuts that go away later. Always ask: "How long does this lower rate last?" Two more things working for you: rents just rose from a year ago for the first time since June 2023 (Realtor.com: $1,692 median, two-bedrooms $1,889), and mortgage applications to buy a home are 18% lower than a year ago. That means fewer buyers competing with you. Your move: what would you ask for on your next offer, a lower price or a lower rate? Tell me below and I'll help you run your numbers. — Coach Joe