Thank you all for taking the time to post such constructive comments and ideas. I have revisited the edit this morning to be sure of what I remembered. I did use masks to recover as much detail in the shadow areas as practical, there is still a minor possibility to recover more, however I could not see any real difference once exported. The colour version looks to have more detail in the shadows but when converted to B&W that detail becomes less distinct, maybe the colour contrast, little as it is, adds just enough as the B&W tonal difference seems less prominent. I really appreciate the comments and ideas though, it was a very harsh reflection from a very bright sun, I should have bracketed on reflection (pun intended) but wanted to see if I could make something of the view, which sitting in the cottage came and went in 10 minutes. So hand held (forgot tripod as you know).