Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
What is this?
Less
More

Memberships

Faith With Aaron

8 members • $9/month

2 contributions to Faith With Aaron
How to Defend Against Protestantism
I realize that a lot of you guys come from Protestant background, so here's a little reading on how to defend AGAINST Protestantism—specifically Sola Scriptura. Know first that Holy Orthodoxy does not deny the authority of Holy Scripture; we simply reject the idea that it is the sole infallible rule of faith. The claim of Sola Scriptura—that Scripture alone is the only necessary and sufficient source of Christian doctrine—is not actually taught in Scripture itself. Where does the Bible say that it is the only rule? It doesn't. In fact, Holy Scripture points to the authority of the Church and its Apostolic Tradition. The Apostle Paul commends the Thessalonians for holding fast to the traditions he taught them, "whether by word or our epistle" (2 Thessalonians 2:15). This passage clearly shows that the spoken, oral tradition had equal authority to the written tradition (Scripture) for the early Church. The Apostle Paul calls the Church the "pillar and ground of the truth" (1 Timothy 3:15). If the Church is the pillar of truth, then the Church must have been established before the New Testament was completed and compiled. The New Testament was written by Apostles and their disciples within the living Tradition of the Church, not dropped out of heaven as an instruction manual centuries later. It was the Church, guided by the Holy Spirit, that determined which books belonged in the Bible canon, centuries after the Apostles died. If the Church had the authority to declare what is Scripture, then the Church's authority must be prior to and equal to** the Scripture it defined. The Orthodox understanding is Holy Tradition (Greek: paradosis) which is the life of the Holy Spirit in the Church, encompassing Scripture, the Ecumenical Councils, the Nicene Creed, the Liturgy, and the writings of the Holy Fathers. Scripture is the highest expression within Holy Tradition, but it is not a separate entity outside of it. Therefore, we hold to the principle that Scripture is rightly understood within the context of the Holy Tradition that gave birth to it.
2 likes • 10d
Ironically, I've found growing up in Protestantism has helped me tremendously in my debates and understanding of the error that is Sola Scriptura. The Church I left, I got to debate the "head elder" after speaking about my conversion and he basically argued only from the perspective of "well I don't think thats the correct understanding" with no additional backing or reason. It was a whole thing lol. It was one of the first issues I've had and overcame in Protestantism. I hope others come to see the fallacy that is Sola Scriptura.
Introduce Yourself Here 😁
This section is for EVERYONE! Please introduce yourself here before doing anything else 🙏🏻 To Christ be the Glory
4 likes • 14d
Greetings to all! The short of who I am: I grew up in a Southern Baptist Church (I am not currently and haven't for a long time) and have dedicated myself to the study of our Faith. I went to Protestant seminary to learn more about, you know, Baptist theology, but I wanted/needed to know the entire Faith from West to East. As I love Apologetics, I began to defend points of Catholicism and Orthodoxy against my Protestant brothers. I viewed the objective understanding of the Faith and of eachother was important. My ministry has always been to see the doctrine of those who would be called Christian was sound and firm. I had reached a point that I could not longer deny Orthodoxy and hold it to be the fullness of the Faith. I continue going to my local parish and talking with my Priest (It's a lot longer story, perhaps I will share in the future) It is a pleasure to meet you all and I look forward to our journey together.
1-2 of 2
Hunter Witzel
2
14points to level up
@hunter-witzel-1320
God's silliest scholar

Active 2d ago
Joined Nov 27, 2025
Powered by