Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
What is this?
Less
More

Memberships

Aquarium Arts Insider Club

79 members • Free

1 contribution to Aquarium Arts Insider Club
My stocking plan 31g lagoon
Recently I had a firefish goby and a royal gramma (from a LFS) in an observation qt. The firefish died in qt I think from stress (no signs of illness). I moved the royal gramma to my display after observation and suddenly after 10 days or so it had major fin damage and couldnt swim. we moved back to qt where it died. I have two theories. 1 is our blue damsel bullying. 2 is that it got caught in the powerhead (sicce nano voyager). Always we planned to rehome the damsel if needed but we didnt see signs. That will be happening now as soon as its possible. Also had already planned to 3d print an anemone guard on the powerhead (still an amateur at modeling and haven't found an existing one that works yet). The royal gramma was larger so it does surprise me that the damsel was the issue. We did see them chasing each other occasionally. But this experience to date has made me rethink my stocking plan and sequence. Also as i learn more we find more fish we want 🤣. This is my current plan. Internet gives conflicting info on stocking levels. I am worried i will overstock. Also want to stock in the best order. Tank is an aio 31G tideline 4 months old with a protein skimmer and a micro refugium in the rear chamber, and I have started adding pods. Working to get phosphates down (above the hanna ulr test range). This "plan" is from google's AI, but it thinks this livestock plan needs a 40G. Ive seem similar plans online for a 32? If it is too tight what should I cut -or- when would we outgrow the tank lol? I have a pair of oscellaris who are hosting the side where the rear overflow is. These are the next steps from AI. The mandarin is a big priority but we love all of these fish. STEP 1: Add Firefish Goby & Tailspot Blenny together │ └── Wait 2 Weeks (Monitor parameter stability) │ ├──> STEP 2: Add Royal Gramma & Banggai Cardinal │ └── Wait 2-3 Weeks (Allows copepod populations to peak) │ ├──> STEP 3: Add Captive-Bred Mandarin Dragonet │ └── Wait until tank is 6-9 months old total
1 like • 24d
@Gavin Rodrigo thanks for the reply! I am definitely a rookie for saltwater. We have had our freshwater (basic rimless 47g with a canister) for about 3 years. I do love the tideline based on my limited experience. I strongly wanted rimless and a plummed and drilled rimless with a sump made my eyes water on the cost. I am running a protein skimmer (icecap 240 aio). I lost 2 different pairs of designer clowns at the beginning in spite of doing seeded ceramic media with a fishless cycle and starter bacteria (did dr tims one and only and now i have a small stash of fritz turbo 900). I do use prime religiously if I am nervous with ammonia but other stores and hobbyists occasionally bring up oxygen levels being impacted by prime. I did have a theory maybe i didnt have great flow thru the mechanical media early on. My ammonia is stable. Hanna reads it at 0.07 at last test. It doesnt want to zero but i have read repeatedly that the hanna ammonia tests are maybe over sensitive. I get nervous about a parasite wiping out my display tank is my main issue on the qt debate but i do think my fish have been overly stressed by the qt too. My thought was get from a guaranteed qt and maybe skip it completely or shorten it to 1-2 weeks. Now that my current fish are finally stable I lean towards caution. Which fish would you say will push me closest to the edge on overstocking?
1 like • 22d
@Gavin Rodrigo makes sense. You explain things very well. I love your videos too. Thank you!
1-1 of 1
Hannah Keirsey
1
2points to level up
@hannah-keirsey-2002
Had Freshwater for about 3 years, new to reefing

Active 17d ago
Joined May 13, 2026
Powered by