Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More
799 contributions to Rebel Economist (Free)
Commodity and non-commodity State money - not so dissimilar?
I give grateful thanks to @Jon Underwood for a Skool conversation that triggered this train of thought. See - https://www.skool.com/stevekeen-free/garbage-from-the-uk-house-of-commons-library?p=f7f23363 Thinking about World X (X for exogenous money), when money was gold, has been useful because it exposed what happened in those bygone days, at the ‘moment of birth’ of old-fashioned commodity money. I hadn't realised that a declaration by the State must be made to create any kind of State money. In my example in the conversation, State-owned gold entered the Treasury as a physical asset. Now I can add a description of commodity money coming into existence by formal declaration - “Hear ye, hear ye. This physical asset is hereby transformed into a monetary asset. There has been a loss of physical assets, reducing the physical equity of the State. There has been a gain in monetary assets, increasing the monetary equity of the State. Let the State’s Accounts show that Transformation. Increase the Asset and Equity entries in those Accounts accordingly. Long live the State”. Two accounting entries were made when commodity money was born. Neither of them was a liability. Of course, that’s an unusual situation in the normal run of accounting when assets and liabilities occur in matched pairs. Something unusual did happen - commodity money was declared into being through transformation of physical into monetary equity. The additional X-world money was nobody’s liability - it wasn’t a debt of the State to anyone. But hang on - States throughout history have surely borrowed gold, especially in times of crisis. But it seems that what they borrowed was the stuff of gold as a physical asset. They didn't borrow accounting entries because those were private money. Prior to the start of the Bank of England, private bank money did not pass as State money. Privare accounting entries could no doubt be borrowed but they could not be merged with State money accounts since the two monies had different status.
0 likes • 13h
@Gerard Borg Thanks for that - your final point is the one I was geting at. Government spending beyond tax (adding equity to the economy) is financed by a reductiion in government equity - which is Steve's 'overall-seesaw'. No debt can be involved since the government, as composite agent, acts alone. The money created is new, not existing money borrowed. I feel the macro/composite view is the more revealing of the situation in toto.
0 likes • 5h
@Jon Underwood Hmmn my problem with debt of a nation is based on what Steve shows and what Frank Newman says, in his book 'Freedom from National Debt' - that this debt is not the conventional kind that needs to be repaid because it wasn't borrowed. It's the use of an accounting liability to record a negative asset - i.e. negative equity which is the necessary counterpart of fiat money existence I'm of course looking at the overall logic from the outside as a non-expert. But the inner working must result in the 'outermost' logic - that negative State equity is positive economy equity.
Garbage from the UK House Of Commons Library
A friend just sent me a link to the 'truth about governmement debt' (hee hee). It's a document from the House of Commons Library https://share.google/eb6g6WlBjESH62ZRE Quoting - "Most borrowing takes place through government bonds called gilts . When investors buy a gilt, they lend money to the government for a fixed period.". Oops - as Steve's accountig shows that's garbage since no money changes hands when Treasury bonds are issued.
1 like • 2d
@Kevin Carney Yes, that sounds like a useful concept. Banknotes and coins are indeed a 'stronger' form of money since they don't depend on the existence of the bank that's bearing demand-liabilities. In the 1930's bankrupcies of many banks, that money vanished ! I suppose by 'final settlement' I really mean 'universal final settlement' independently of context. So it's actually cash that fills that role, as State money 'no questions asked'. Indeed, someone at Skool (I've lost who) recently pointed out - passing as State money is what defines bank liabilities as money - and Steve agreed.
0 likes • 1d
I've heard Michael Kumhof say "Many things are money, so more some less". He went on to reserve the word money for State money and used the plural 'monies' to mean other stuff, even when it was singular. So your 'air miles' would be monies, in that useage. Funds still seems like a good and specific collective-word for bank assets though !
Tim Winton on climate calamity
Steve is more than direct in his criticism of climate-change deniers. Yet a Guardian correspondent uses even stronger language. See - https://www.theguardian.com/membership/2026/aug/24/this-is-not-a-natural-calamity-it-is-being-done-to-us-knowingly He says “Global heating is an outrage, not a tragedy.”… “This is something that is being done to us. Knowingly. Which makes it a crime. A narrow class of people is profiting from our anguish… What they care about is money. Not just enough to get by on. Not even enough to become grotesquely rich with. They want the kind of money that bends others to their will.”. The article ends with what could be seen as an advertisement for the Guardian, thought it is likely true. The picture that illustrates the article is distinctly suitable.
Tim Winton on climate calamity
0 likes • 3d
@James Clark Just so - there is something 'dark' in ordinary society which I've only recently begun to put my finger on. All I know is that I've never, seemingly even as a kid, much felt that way. I'm talking about deference to those in authority. It seem to be built-in unconsciously to quite a few people. Very few of my social circle, through the decades, has thought that way - so there might have been some kind of 'self-selecting grouping' going on. Politicians seem particularly adept at exploiting it, in those who think that way. It's odd, 'cos I've never been much of a rebel yet psychologically I've never been much of a 'sheep to be led' either …
Castigo Nacional
It may seem obvious that languages aren’t the same, but they’re different in more than their formal structure. Welsh is a far better language to be emotional in that English is. For powerful expressiveness in a few words; as for righteous indignation, I’d say Spanish takes the biscuit. See attached, about what just happened in the US. And for may be about to happen, see - https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/nov/05/tech-barons-america-musk-bezos-zuckerberg
Castigo Nacional
1 like • 14d
@Patrick Cunningham I think the bit about the 'tech bros' is very significant. Those guys bet their business-model on Maga-thinking being a permanent move to never-ending wealth concentration at the top. Musk, in the end, might be as big a loser as Trump , along with the Borg-like clones-of-Trump that call themselves the Republican Party.
1 like • 14d
@Patrick Cunningham The Dems have a dilemma - pursue legislation to improve Americans' lives - which Trump will likely veto - or pusue subpoenas against corrupt actors, which Trump will have a much harder time blocking. Trump's lackey-lawyer, appointed to the DoJ, has already resigned !
‘Regenerative Economics’ - a 2025 book by John Fullerton
I came upon this book because it shares a title with the workshop I recently attended by Jennifer Brandsberg-Engelmann. See https://www.skool.com/stevekeen/rebuilding-early-education-in-economics-regenerative-economics?p=c16f2fba I’m not sure if there’s a connection but this book has entirely the same viewpoint as Jennifer’s, even though she has a focus on secondary-school education. Fullerton aims at a wider audience, in a book that doesn’t offer solutions so much as frame the right questions - or rather it sets up an entirely different and appropriately-realistic attitude of mind. It address the problem that @Patrick Cunningham seems to have encountered recently with the UK Green Party. See https://www.skool.com/stevekeen/the-green-party-are-idealouges?p=4e83c3df Fullerman seems to be a classic case of the Prodigal Son, since he resigned from a top position at JP Morgan and spent at least a decade discovering all that was wrong with the world he had worked and prospered in for 20 years. I think his book is very relevant to the breadth of experience and interests that Skool members seem to have in looking for ways to reject and oppose the status quo that has led humanity to the brink. Might @Lucy Trinder especially like this book for its emphasis on holistic thinking? I especially like its insightful argument for something very innovative, suggesting an entirely new social institution based on recognising and claiming universally-shared ownership of the commons. Fullerton isn’t the source of that idea, but he makes a cracking good case for it. For me, that section alone justifies reading the book, because of the cascade of social and environmental justice that would likely result.
‘Regenerative Economics’ - a 2025 book by John Fullerton
0 likes • 14d
@Stephen Hinton Thanks Steven, I clearly didn't read carefully enough. I'd say the ways in which you detect "he won't go there" would be very significant to publicise. My take on what Jennifer Brandsberg-Engelmann presented was that she much supported issues around degrowth - that was a topic in her session, though she had little time and too many topics. But her position was that stopping/reversing growth to be within habitable boundaries, and re-distributing wealth dramatically as a consequence, is what she saw as normally-assumed by many kids and teenagers today. She felt that the very young (pre-adult) already see what what the adults mostly don't …
1 like • 14d
@Stephen Hinton Hmmn, I'll re-examine Jennifer's stuff to see if she realises that. Her session was, in its background vibes, focussed on restoring Nature's capacity to recycle and regenerate. But that clearly doesn't apply to minerals … You make a key point. Has anyone yet used ambient energy to recover (should we say re-mine?) minerals from rubbish-dumps ? (some of which are huge).
1-10 of 799
Alwyn Lewis
7
5,993 points to level up
@alwyn-lewis-1564
Retired signal-processing engineer, university lecturer. Interested in money system post '08 via Positive Money, economics interest grew thereafter.

Active 4h ago
Joined Jan 11, 2023
UK
Powered by