Designing Relationships That Keep Customers Coming Back

Every Sunday, I write a newsletter on LinkedIn called Fueling The Marketing Mind and while I'm a marketer first, in these newsletter editions I always share how readers can use AI to execute the lessons and frameworks.

Today’s episode explored something every business depends on but very few actually design with intention:

Customer loyalty.

Not the points-card version.

Not the “we hope they come back” version.

I mean actual emotional loyalty. The kind that makes people stay even when they have other options.

Here’s the big idea I unpacked:

A customer never leaves all at once. The relationship fades one micro-moment at a time.

A delayed reply.

A flat experience.

A moment where the customer quietly thinks, “Ah… they don’t really care.”

The flip side is also true:

Loyalty isn’t built in grand gestures. It’s built in the tiny, intentional choices you make every day.

And when you zoom out, you notice something powerful:

Loyalty is emotional long before it’s financial.

People return because they feel safe, understood, and supported... not because the product is perfect.

Here are a few principles from today’s episode that I think every entrepreneur, operator, and builder should revisit:

1. Loyalty is connection, not convenience.

Customers don’t stay because your product works.

They stay because the relationship works.

2. Consistency compounds.

Every “we’ve got you” moment is a deposit in the trust bank.

3. Recognition matters.

When people feel remembered — not processed — everything changes.

4. Intention turns transactions into relationships.

Most brands optimize for speed.

Winning brands optimize for care.

5. Advocacy is engineered, not accidental.

If you design the right loyalty moments, customers don’t just stay… they start telling your story for you.

In the newsletter, I also broke down my C.I.R.C.L.E. Loyalty Loop Framework (Connection, Intention, Recognition, Consistency, Lift, Empowerment), plus AI prompts you can use to design your own loyalty system.

If you want to read the full episode, the PDF is attached below.

We aren’t allowed to share external links in this community but I still wanted you to have access. So I uploaded my final draft directly from Google Docs here for anyone who wants the deep dive.

Would love to know: What’s one small loyalty moment you’ve experienced (or created) that made a brand unforgettable?

15 comments