If you're a coach who isn't technical, the simplest platform is one that already bundles your community, course hosting, and payments, so you're not stitching three tools together. Here's the checklist to pick one and get it set up.
Checklist: 📝
✅ Pick a platform that handles community, course hosting, and payments under one login.
✅ Check if it needs its own website or domain, or if it can go live on its own page.
✅ Look at how members actually talk to you and each other, through posts, comments, or direct messages, without a separate app.
✅ Confirm there's a free way to try it before you pay for anything.
✅ See if it has levels or tiers built in, so you can gate content without custom code.
✅ Check whether posts are public by default, since that affects whether people can find you outside the platform too.
✅ Confirm payment collection is built in, not bolted on through a third tool.
✅ Run through this before you pick a platform, not after you've already paid for one.
Skool in a Box walks through this inside one Claude artifact. You answer a few questions and get paste-ready copy for your community name, About page, levels, and welcome post, laid out in the order it goes into Skool with a checklist.
Do I need a website first? No. A platform that already includes a community page can stand in as your site, so there's nothing separate to build.
Will my posts show up in Google?
Public posts inside platforms like Skool can get indexed. One host reported her public post reaching #2 for her main keyword in about a week (Source: Stephanie Hetu, Skool Insider), though that's one person's result, not a guarantee.