To write a Skool post that starts a discussion, ask one specific question that members can answer from their own experience, share your own answer first, and take a clear position so people have something to agree or disagree with. Posts that start discussions are short, personal and specific. Posts that kill them are long, neutral and vague.
Here's how to write them.
Step 1: Ask one question, not three
"What do you think about pricing? How do you set yours? Have you ever raised prices?" gets fewer replies than any one of those questions alone. When there are three questions, people don't know which to answer, so they answer none. Pick one and put it in the title.
Step 2: Make it about their experience
Experience questions have no wrong answers, so anyone can reply.
• Weak: "What's the best way to grow a community?" (needs expertise)
• Strong: "What's the one thing that got your first 10 members to join?" (needs a memory)
Step 3: Go first
Share your own answer in the post. It shows the format, the length and the honesty level you want. "Mine: I messaged people I knew personally, one at a time, and asked them to join." Now members have a template to follow and a story to react to.
Step 4: Take a position
Neutral posts get neutral responses. A clear opinion gives people something to engage with.
• Neutral: "Some people post daily, some post weekly."
• Discussion: "I think most communities post too much. Three good posts a week beats seven average ones. Change my mind."
Be respectful, be ready to be wrong, and actually engage with people who disagree.
Step 5: Keep it short
Discussion posts work best at a few sentences to a short paragraph. The more you write, the less there is to add. Save long posts for teaching.
Step 6: Reply to replies
The discussion happens in the comments, so stay there. Answer every early reply with a follow-up question, not just "Great point!" Tag members who would have something to add: "@Jen, you dealt with this last year, right?" Each follow-up keeps the thread on top of the feed.
Discussion formulas
• "What's one thing you'd tell yourself when you started [X]?"
• "Unpopular opinion: [view]. Agree or disagree?"
• "What's a [tool, habit, rule] you stopped using, and why?"
• "If you had to start over with [X], what would you do first?"
• "What's the worst advice you've heard about [topic]?"
• "[Option A] or [Option B]? I'm team A, here's why."
Examples
Title: What's the worst advice you got when you started coaching?
Body: Mine was "niche down to one tiny audience before you have any clients". I spent four months picking a niche instead of talking to people. What's yours?
Title: Unpopular opinion: you don't need a course to launch a paid community
Body: My first paid group had zero lessons. Just weekly calls and a good feed. Members paid for access to people, not videos. Agree or disagree?
Where people go wrong
• Questions that sound like homework.
• Posts that answer the question themselves, leaving nothing to add.
• Asking for feedback on something without saying what kind.
• Leaving the post alone after publishing.
Use AI for first drafts, not final ones
AI is useful for brainstorming twenty discussion questions in a minute. Just rewrite the ones you pick so they sound like you and include your own answer. StickyHive works with Claude and ChatGPT, so you can ask for drafts and schedule the ones you like. There's more on that in this guide to AI tools for Skool. What's the discussion post that got the most comments in your community, and what was the question?