So I've been building out this dataset the past few days — long-run S&P (Shiller's data, goes back to 1871) and Nikkei 225, and stripping both down to the ugliest, most honest version I could make them. No dividends reinvested. Deflated for inflation. Just the raw price, doing what the raw price actually did.
Here's why that matters. Every "stocks always go up" chart you've ever seen is wearing two coats of paint. Coat one: dividends reinvested, which most retail investors don't actually do with precision, and which flatters the buy-and-hold case by a lot over long horizons. Coat two: nominal terms, meaning it's not adjusted for the fact that a dollar in 1990 bought more than a dollar today. Strip both coats off, sand it back to bare wood, and you see what the asset actually did to your purchasing power, full stop.
Then I ran a stupid-simple trend filter on top of the bare wood version — 200-day MA for Nikkei, Faber's classic 10-month SMA for the S&P. Same treatment both sides, right? No dividends for either line, same deflator for either line. Not comparing a flattered buy-and-hold against a bare-bones timing strategy, that would be cheating.
The timed version won. Not by a little. Nikkei especially real, price-only, buy-and-hold spent DECADES underwater after 1990, and the 200-day version was compounding the whole time. The S&P version is less dramatic but the same shape, going back a hundred and fifty years.
Now — before anyone screenshots this and goes "Rick says index funds are a scam," slow down, that's not what I'm saying, and here's the honesty part that actually matters more than the flex:
Q: Does this hold up if you'd stopped the chart in a different year?
A: Not perfectly. Look at Nikkei mid-2010s, buy-and-hold actually claws back a chunk of the gap during that bull run. A cumulative curve ending today is vulnerable to "well you just got lucky with the endpoint." I'd want rolling 10-year windows before I'd put real money conviction behind the headline number, not just one long path that happens to end well.
Q: What's the flat-cash assumption doing?
A: Right now, sitting out of the market earns literally 0% nominal in this version, which means it BLEEDS against inflation while flat. That's actually conservative in favor of buy-and-hold, not against it — a real allocator parks that cash in T-bills, and the gap would probably be wider with that included, not narrower.
Q: Trading costs?
A: Not in this version yet. Nikkei especially chops around its 200MA a lot in the 90s-2000s, and every one of those crosses is a round trip you're not paying for here. That's next on the list before I'd call this bulletproof.