PTN INSIDER REPORT 012 / Spotify & BMG Go Direct — The Split Shift / October 10, 2025

Oct 10 (edited) • PTN Insider/Flashwire Report

📍 1. CONTEXT / INDUSTRY SHIFT

Spotify and BMG have quietly rewritten the streaming playbook. They’ve signed a direct U.S. publishing license, cutting around the Mechanical Licensing Collective (MLC) - the body that processes mechanical royalties for most publishers under the Copyright Royalty Board model.

Why it matters: it marks the first time a major publisher has opted out of the collective system and gone direct. That’s not just a contract, it’s a declaration of independence.

This shift means publishers can negotiate their own mechanical rates, reporting cadence, and payment pipelines. It also means streaming services could face a fragmented royalty landscape where deals are private and data transparency gets murkier.

📂 2. CASE FOCUS / BREAKDOWN

• BMG’s move: The company frames it as “faster, fairer, and more direct” payment to songwriters.

• Spotify’s motive: Simplify reporting, reduce latency, and lock in favorable economics before more publishers demand renegotiations.

• System crack: If Sony or Kobalt follows, the MLC could lose leverage and scale, effectively returning us to pre-2018 chaos when every service had separate licenses.

• Creator angle: Speed of payment improves, but independent writers may lose the unified protection and audit power the MLC provided.

📈 3. STRATEGY OR BUSINESS PRINCIPLE

This is a “split shift” moment - the era of uniform streaming splits may be fading.BMG’s strategy is vertical control: own the data, the negotiation, and the payout line. Spotify’s strategy is horizontal leverage: play direct with the biggest catalog owners to stabilize margins.

The underlying principle: whoever controls the interface between data and payout controls the future of creator economics.

✅ 4. TAKEAWAYS / ACTION STEPS

Understand your royalty chain

Know whether your publisher is part of the MLC, a direct license, or both. The difference can affect not only your income but how long it takes to reach you.

Watch for new deal templates

If this model works, “direct publisher streaming licenses” could become the norm. Expect new hybrid contracts or collection terms in 2026.

Audit your data visibility

The trade-off for faster money may be reduced transparency. Creators must demand access to usage and payment data to maintain leverage.

Position for agility

Smaller publishers and self-released creators might soon need digital infrastructure (metadata tracking, royalty analytics, rights registration) to compete in a fractured licensing ecosystem.

🔬 PTN LENS – Visual or Language Framing

Think of it as the royalty pipeline fracturing like a river delta: faster tributaries for some, shallows for others. In a world of fragmented flows, survival favors creators who can map their own routes.

🔍 5. FINAL REFLECTION / CREATOR LENS

For creators, this move isn’t just about payouts - it’s about trust. If the biggest players can rewrite the system in private, smaller voices must learn to read the undercurrents. Knowing your rights, your flow, and your data becomes the new creative literacy.

The artist who understands the business system will be the one who survives it.

📚 PTN difference.

We don’t just analyze the system - we operate inside it, with our eyes wide open.

Right now, we play by the rules we’ve been given - the briefs, the splits, the backend grind. But everything we build - the workflows, the trust, the visibility - is designed to give us the position to change those rules.

We’re not just getting through the gates. We’re training creators to build their own floor once they’re in - and eventually, to redesign the whole building.

And that’s the PTN difference.

---

📎 SOURCE SIGNALS – Full Links

Spotify Newsroom – BMG and Spotify sign new US direct licensing agreement

https://newsroom.spotify.com/2025-10-08/bmg-spotify-direct-licensing-us-deal

Billboard – Spotify signs new deal with BMG to deliver greater value for songwriters

https://www.billboard.com/pro/spotify-bmg-sign-direct-licensing-deal-songwriter-royalties

Music Business Worldwide – BMG and Spotify ink new US direct publishing licensing deal

https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/spotify-and-bmg-strike-new-direct-multiyear-us-publishing-licensing-deal

The Hollywood Reporter – Spotify signs licensing publishing deal with BMG

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/music/music-industry-news/spotify-signs-deal-with-bmg-1236395359

2 comments