Case Study: How MeUndies Retains Customers (and Pays for Themselves)

MeUndies is a subscription-based underwear and loungewear brand renowned for its fun prints, inclusive sizing, and ultra-soft materials. Their membership model (not just a subscription), transforms customers into loyal fans.

The Retention Strategy That Works

1. Membership Economics

Non-members pay ~$18/pair; members pay ~$14, a clear financial incentive.
Members also get early access to exclusive prints and partner discounts.This structure boosts LTV. Members spend 3× more than non-members and make up 50% of total customers

2. Novelty & Emotional Value

MeUndies releases exclusive prints weekly. This surprise element creates emotional anticipation, making buying feel like an event .
Members feel “special,” connect with the product, and want to stay for new releases.

3. Community Feedback & Influence

MeUndies invites member input on new designs, fostering ownership and deep loyalty
Social media features real users, amplifying belonging and encouraging referrals.

4. Smart Churn Management

Their “Match Me” program lets you add items for others. It makes cancellations harder because it affects others.
They also survey cancelers, learning why people leave and adjusting accordingly.

5. Tech Infrastructure That Supports Retention

MeUndies built a custom subscription engine (handling rotating styles, bundles, and mystery packs) improving operations and decreasing friction.

Why It Pays for Itself

Repeat purchases offset acquisition costs. Instead of losing money on the first order, MeUndies makes it back through loyal members.
Higher AOV + Stronger Loyalty: Members not only buy more frequently, but also spend more per order.
Lower churn with built-in emotional hooks: novelty, belonging, and community prevent cancelations.

Retention isn’t just about reminders. It’s about making customers feel connected. Our goal should be to create reasons to stay: emotional, functional, and playful. That’s how retention becomes a growth machine.

What other DTC Brands have great retention strategies?

2 comments