Catholic and Christian schools traditionally think about advancement in patterns that would be familiar to anyone who has spent time in or around these Organizations. The primary donors have always been, and continue to be, the existing pool of parents, alumni, grandparents, board members and friends of the school. As we approach January 1st, the Education Freedom Tax Credit is going to give schools around the country a reason to extend that pool of donors, by engaging more deliberately with the whole church community.
This doesn’t require turning your parish, congregation, priest or pastor into a scholarship administrator, or donor development officer. Instead, we should highlight something faith-based schools have understood implicitly for generations: the mission of Christian education belongs to more people than the families currently paying tuition. While the donations themselves go to the SGO, as opposed to directly to the school, it is incredibly likely that taxpayers will first hear about the program via their church community.
These taxpayers may be parishioners whose children graduated twenty years ago, under a different administrative team. They may be church members whose own children attended public school and want other families to have access to Christian education. They may be local professionals, business owners, coaches, or young families for whom a major gift was never realistic. All of these people are currently living and working within your larger community, and that means your school’s potential community of support under the EFTC is significantly larger than your advancement database says it is!
However, when marketing and recommending the program, I suggest you do so carefully. After all, a taxpayer seeking the federal credit must donate to an eligible SGO, not the parish or school directly. With that in mind, I advise that Church and school leaders use this opportunity to help explain why Christian education matters within your community, and why you selected your specific SGO partner(s) to help facilitate their donations. Not only does this help introduce the EFTC program to people who otherwise may not have heard about it, it also creates a warm introduction for the development of durable donor relationships.
While I do believe that a tax benefit can gather quite a bit of attention, as the sentiment tracking project done by my friends at FundEDU indicates, I firmly believe that a tax benefit alone isn’t enough to make the mission personal. That still takes communication, gratitude, evidence of impact, and a reason for the donor to care about the students behind the scholarship. This is where having a good partner is incredibly important to develop and reinforce the same point from the tax-credit side. By providing school-facing services including donor outreach, program navigation, coordination with scholarship organizations, and tracking contributions through the process, organizations like FundEDU have helped schools in Pennsylvania build tax credit based donor bases for years now, and their expertise can be incredibly valuable as we look towards implementing the first federal school choice program in US history.
So, before 2027, I suggest that school and church leaders decide what an appropriate partnership looks like. Who explains the program? Who points taxpayers toward which SGO(s)? What information can/should be shared through church communications? How are tax-specific questions referred elsewhere? How does the school report back on what scholarship support made possible?
Ultimately, no community is served well when every sermon is turned into a fundraising pitch, or when the bulletin exists purely to advertise and solicit. However, here the goal is simpler: make the EFTC opportunity understandable, leave the tax and scholarship explanations to the experts, and direct the people in your community who care about Christian education how to participate. We all know that private education has always depended on people who support the mission, even when their own children are no longer sitting in the classroom, so lets use these next few months to make it easy for them to do so!