The answer, if you extend to 50 years, would be no real difference. Over the past 20 years, significantly more in red states. From the research I did into the question, it has more to do with fundamental population growth than it does with specific real estate policy. In fact, most blue states put in rent controls and other legislation that limit supply, increasing the pricing of real estate over time, artificially inflating the value disproportionately to the population growth. My takeaway is that, regardless of policy, the fundamentals of supply and demand still dominate long-term value. If your product is housing for humans your best investment will be following where the people want to live and are actively moving. That happened to be an aggressive increase in movement to red states from blue states over the past two decades.